Doing 55 in a 54

Matt Barganier, July 28, 2009

Kelley Vlahos has a great piece today on the Henry Gates affair and the larger problems of which it’s a symptom. One such problem is the ever increasing number of pretexts on which the authorities can interrogate, search, assault, and arrest citizens. The authority figure, equipped with endless excuses to initiate an interaction with the citizen, from an expired tag to a false burglar alarm to an alleged whiff of what might be a controlled substance, uses his or her superior knowledge of legal arcana to find some way to put the citizen behind bars.  For instance, what struck me when reading the policeman’s account of the Gates incident was a small detail: the repeated use of the term “tumultuous.” It appears three times in the brief report in descriptions of Gates’ behavior. Why was the cop fixated on this SAT word?

Turns out, it appears in the Massachusetts statute defining disorderly conduct. The cop goaded the agitated Gates into stepping outside of his house (he made sure to give a reason for this in the report – poor acoustics in Gates’ kitchen!) to create the grounds for an arrest.  The cop already knew the specific – though vague and debatable – adjective he should use in his report to make the charge sound incontestable to the lawnorder crowd.

The proliferation of new laws in the wake of 9/11, all full of vague and debatable terms, has given the authorities infinite points of entry into all of our lives. They truly can arrest first and read the statutes later; you’re sure to have done something wrong. Even if they eventually drop the charges or fail to convict you, don’t count on getting any compensation for your anxiety, lost time, injuries, or legal fees.

An analogous situation prevails in international affairs, where the global police churn out endless legal pretexts for subjecting whole countries to full body-cavity searches, house arrest, assault, and capital punishment, and we’re watching it play out yet again in the case of Iran. But that’s a post for another day.

39 Responses to “Doing 55 in a 54”

  1. I know many people focus on this as a racial issue. I am glad this article did not. The police have been tought a whole new form of tactics when it come to dealing with the public. They are now supposed to project and image of power and that their authority is not to be questioned. Some of this is common sense, in that the streets that some of these cops patrol is violent to an extreem. However, much of it is also simply the love of power. I have been manhandled or threatend by police on a number of occations. I am always polite but willing to assert my rights. I make it a point to know them (my rights) so I feel more free in exercising them than most people would. In this case I would not have allowed the police to get me outside. Just by stepping outside he found himself in a different legal situtation. This is a common tactic.

  2. Part 2
    If the police come to your door do not allow them to enter and do not go outside. If they had propable cause to enter they wouldn't need to ask. If they had an arrest warrant they would simply arrest you and take you to the station. In this situation he would have been smart to have simply stood in his doorway shown his proof and asked them to leave. As Nancy Reagon Said "Just Say NO!"

  3. 100% agree with BradSmith

  4. Thanks Brad – I've a feeling these pragmatic tips will become increasingly valuable in the future.

  5. […] source […]

  6. The ancient Roman historian Tacitus put it this way: "The more corrupt the state, the more numerous the laws." By that standard, the United States is pretty Goddamn corrupt.

    By its nature, police work attracts authoritarian types, the kind who are psychologically dangerous when armed with authority. Officer Asshole, with his gun and his shield, regards any dissing as a mortal affront to his very being.

    There are two kinds of cop: One stands behind his shield, the other hides behind his. There are too many of the latter bastards.

  7. And don't forget their willing "enablers" such as those private-citizen, SUV driving,numbskulls with the displayed PBA /Law Enforcement gold shields in the front window of their cars which are designed to intimidate others into getting out of their way or for their personal justification for driving drunk.

  8. Dead on the money. We're living in a fascist police state and few recognize the fact or care. We've been conditioned since roughly 1894, when the two-party system ceased to exist. What's it going to take to turn this around?

  9. Total ecomomic collapse followed my State Successions.

  10. The smart-arse approach of the wearers-of-stormtrooper-drag reminds me of something attributed to that vile megalomaniac Richelieu: "give me six lines from the most honest man, and I will find in it something to hang him".

    Our collective response ought to be "show me the contract I signed that said I was prepared to obey you, or fuck off".

    This idea that we are the livestock of the State has got to be put paid to: I don't care how many of these 'we own you' scumbags has to die.

    If it (the required number of political-parasite and Sardaukar deaths) was zero, that would be cool: a move to a voluntaryist structure without bloodshed would be terrific.

    But if it was necessary (to paraphrase Diderot) to bludgeon the last politician to death with the severed arm of the last police sniper, then so be it.

    As our Frog mates say: j'en ai eu assez, et j'en ai rien à foutre.



  11. I'm of the definite opinion that the fate of that Romanian bastard Ceaucescu and his secret police cronies should never be forgotten.

  12. Ceaucescu rightly was shot, but it was his cronies (who had turned on him) who did it. Probably they are still in power. Quis custodiet ipsos custodos?

  13. Yer right, Matt.

    And I agree with ya and everything but face it, if you are the typical AmeroConned Sheeple you WANT s big gummymit that will put its arms around you and hug the stuffing outta ya.

    After all, freedom is on the march, it takes a village, yer gummymint loves ya and everything it does is for da childern… least that's what our politicians always tell us and the sheeple swallow these lines whole.

    So as the economy and society detiorate further the AmeroCon Sheeple will demand an even bigger police state…

  14. The whole idea of a government owned and controlled police force is only about 150 years old. It's clearly an experiment that's failed.

  15. Allow some prospective on it from Russia…
    Year was 1979 and USSR entered Afganistan – Afgan war started.

    My reaction to that news was “Or, Sh.t”. Then – people that talked in public of course would approve the war. But maybe less then 30% at most would approve it in private talk.

    Now – fast forward to 2003. I see the invasion of Iraq on TV (I lived in the US then) and say “Oh, Sh.t – not again… Not another Empire going down – not another Perestrojka and following “Perestrelka” (“Firefight”)… So, I left.

    BUT – since unlike the USSR in 2003 MOST US people I’ve talked to approved the Iraq war…

    It means that US people are more brainwashed then Russian during the 70s. Being brainwashed does not help much against structural crysis. So – US would rather be following the path of Germany during 30s.

    Which means we’ll eventually get full blown international “perestrelka” with nuclear arms involved.

    Is there anything to be done? No. US people en mass don’t have any historical memory about what is war on their own soil. It is VERY unpleasant. Besides – China will stop sending goods :-)

  16. you’re sure to have done something wrong. Even if they eventually drop the charges or fail to convict you, don’t count on getting any compensation for your anxiety, lost time, injuries, or legal fees.

  17. Great Post.
    Contact Miami medical malpractice lawyer if you need legal advise on medical malpractice.

  18. Its a 9/11 effect and from my point of view somehow it has rather importance.

  19. In case face with any medical malpractice, you can seek assistance from a Miami Medical Malpractice attorney.

  20. The proliferation of new laws in the wake of 9/11, all full of vague and debatable terms, has given the authorities infinite points of entry into all of our lives. They truly can arrest first and read the statutes later; you’re sure to have done something wrong. Even if they eventually drop the charges or fail to convict you, don’t count on getting any compensation for your anxiety, lost time, injuries, or legal fees.houston wedding limo

  21. The best blog always in th? nh?a serves information regarding products ads

  22. This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really helpful information. Keep it up.

    Panduan Judi Bola, Modifikasi Mobil Motor, Bokep Streaming, Panduan Casino Online, Panduan Poker Online

  23. Camping has normally been one of the best ways to see nature and her miracles. Particularly, camping in the mountains. However, your camping journey could as effortlessly turn into a disaster is mother nature will get into considered one of her terrific rages, and also you never provide the right clothing to shield yourself in opposition to the icy winds.t? l?nh Panasonic|máy in ?a n?ng HP|t? l?nh toshiba|T? l?nh panasonic t?t|Máy in ?a n?ng|máy in

  24. The proliferation of new laws in the wake of 9/11, all full of vague and debatable terms, has given the authorities infinite points of entry into all of our lives. They truly can arrest first and read the statutes later; you’re sure to have done something wrong.

  25. Thông th??ng HDD có 2 chu?n ph? bi?n ???c dùng cho laptop là IDE và SATA. Do ?ó vi?c ??u tiên xác ??nh xem laptop c?a b?n s? d?ng HDD chu?n nào. Chúng ta có th? s? d?ng ph?n m?m AIDA64 ?? ki?m tra th?ng s? c?a ? c?ng,
    thay o cung laptop v? các thông tin c? b?n nh? lo?i giao ti?p, t?c ?? vòng quay, b? nh? ??m…
    Sau khi xác ??nh ???c lo?i giao ti?p c?a ? c?ng, còn 2 thông tin khác mà chúng ta c?n quan tâm là dung l??ng và kích th??c ?. Còn m?t thông s? quan tr?ng n?a là s? vòng quay. Cu?i cùng là tính n?ng ch?ng s?c, giúp b?o v? ? c?ng khi b? rung ??ng, nh?m b?o v? d? li?u bên trong. Smart Care s?n sàng ngu?n linh ph? ki?n d?i dào, t? v?n t?n tâm cho quý khách hàng các thông s? chi ti?t ?? ch?n l?a và thay ? c?ng laptop phù h?p.
    M?t s? hình ?nh sau giúp các b?n hi?u các quy trình c?n b?n trên:
    ?? ti?n hành chúng ta c?n m?t tu?c n? vít ?? m? n?p máy. ??u tiên chúng ta tháo pin máy ?? tránh cho máy b? s?c ?i?n, sau ?ó xác ??nh các ?c vít c?n tháo ra.

  26. Công ty C? Ph?n Thiên Quân(Thien Quan JSC) chuyên ho?t ??ng trong các l?nh v?c: Kinh doanh nh?p kh?u Nguyên li?u Thu?c Thú Y – Thu?c Thú Y Th?y S?n; Nguyên li?u th?c ?n trong ch?n nuôi và các ch? ph?m sinh h?c, hóa ch?t dùng trong Thú Y và Thú Y Th?y S?n.

    Nh?p kh?u và kinh doanh phân ph?i hàng nguyên li?u thu?c th?y s?n g?m các nhóm: Thu?c kháng sinh các lo?i, Vitamin, Acid amin, ch?t x? lý n??c, nhóm vi sinh và m?t s? ch?t b? sung khác… ???c nh?p tr?c ti?p t? các n??c nh? M?, ?n ??, Nh?t, Bungary, Tây Ban Nha, Trung Qu?c, … Khách hàng c?a chúng tôi là các công ty s?n xu?t thu?c thú y – th?y s?n, các nhà máy s?n xu?t th?c ?n gia súc và nhà máy s?n xu?t th?c ?n th?y s?n, các trang tr?i ch?n nuôi và các c?a hàng, ??i lý trên toàn qu?c.

    V?i giá c? phù h?p và ch?t l??ng luôn ???c ??m b?o ?úng theo tiêu chu?n c?a nhà s?n xu?t, cùng v?i ??i ng? nhân viên chuyên môn cao, luôn t? duy sáng t?o, ??y nhi?t huy?t, giàu kinh nghi?m, nhi?t tình, t?n tâm ch?m sóc khách hàng, chúng tôi luôn t? tin mang ??n cho khách hàng s? an tâm v? ch?t l??ng, hi?u qu? cao trong kinh doanh và s? hài lòng tuy?t ??i.

    ? S? m?nh:

    – Luôn mang ??n cho khách hàng nh?ng s?n ph?m có ch?t l??ng t?t nh?t v?i giá c? h?p lý nh?t;
    – Luôn mang l?i hi?u qu? thi?t th?c cho khách hàng và ng??i s? d?ng s?n ph?m;

    – Luôn ý th?c và h??ng ??n nh?ng ho?t ??ng góp ph?n làm cu?c s?ng t?t ??p h?n.
    ? Giá tr? c?t lõi:
    V?i ni?m tin và s? phát tri?n c?a m?t n??c mà nên Nông Nghi?p là ch? y?u, công ty C? Ph?n Thiên Quân ??nh h??ng phát tri?n thành m?t công ty v?ng m?nh trong ngành Nông Nghi?p. Thiên Quân xác ??nh s? là m?t công ty chuyên nghi?p và luôn cung c?p nh?ng gi?i pháp hi?u qu? ??n khách hàng, cùng khách hàng phát tri?n, cùng h??ng ??n s? th?nh v??ng!

  27. Vi?c s? h?u m?t làn da tr?ng m?n ,là ni?m mong m?i c?a m?i ph? n? .Có nhi?u l?a ch?n :dùng kem d??ng da, s?a t?m tr?ng da ,s?a t?m t?t cho da và nhi?u bi?n pháp b?o v? da khác. Tuy nhiên dùng s?n ph?m nào thì c?ng c?n theo nh?ng b??c d??i ?ây ?? ??m b?o phát huy hi?u qu? nh?t ?? ch?m sóc làn da c?a b?n. Phái ??p luôn lo l?ng b?n kho?n v? vi?c l?a ch?n lo?i kem d??ng da nào t?t nh?t và cách s? d?ng sao cho hi?u qu? cao nh?t , hôm nay trong bài vi?t này Ts.BS Doãn Ng?c Vân khoa da li?u b?nh vi?n ?H Y D??c s? h??ng d?n chi ti?t v? vi?c ch?n l?a s? s?ng các lo?i kem trang ?i?m và s?a d??ng tr?ng da c?ng nh? cách ch?m sóc làn da t?i nhà

  28. ??? ???????
    ??? ????????
    ??? ???
    ??? ?????
    ??? ??? ?????
    ??? ????????
    ??? ???
    ????? ??
    ???? ??
    ????? ????
    ???? ?? ????
    ????? ??
    ????? ??? ?????
    ????? ?????
    ????? ???

  29. ??? ??????? ??? ???????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ???
    ??? ??????
    ??? ???

  30. ??? ??
    ?????? ?????
    ????? ???
    ??? ????
    ???? ?? ????
    ???? ????
    ??????? ?????

  31. ??? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ???????
    ??? ??
    ???? ?? ????
    ??? ?? ????
    ??? ???
    ??? ????
    ???? ???
    ??? ????? ?????
    ??? ???? ?????
    ??? ???? ?????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ???

  32. ??? ??? ?????

  33. ??? ??????
    ??? ?????
    ??? ????

  34. msry

  35. ????? ????

  36. Tr??c khi Mascherano b? bu?c xem ty le ca cuoc truc tuyen t?i tr?n thu?, hai ??ng ??i n?i ti?ng c?a anh t?i Barca là Messi và Neymar c?ng b? ?i?u tra.
    t? l? kèo bóng ?á hôm nay
    Lionel Messi c?ng t?ng b? nha cai uy tin bu?c t?i tr?n thu? b?n quy?n hình ?nh. Ngoài ra, cha con ngôi sao ng??i Argentna còn gian l?n t?i 3 tri?u euro trong kho?ng th?i gian t? n?m 2006 t?i 2009.

  37. Stoke would become Barcelona‘But can he do it on a wet Tuesday night at Stoke? tip mien phi hang ngay’ In his continued effort to answer the age-old adage, Mark Hughes added Moha El Ouriachi and Ibrahim Afellay to his collection of former Barcelona stars, joining Bojan and Marc Muniesa. With the playing style completely revamped from the days of Tony Pulis, and talented fanny merchant Xherdan Shaqiri also joining, this was a ‘Barca B’ side in the making. Back-to-back finishes of ninth represented Stoke’s best ever in the Premier League; Hughes was tipped to continue the upward trajectory into a third consecutive season.
    Therefore, few would have expected their h??ng d?n cá ?? ?á banh  first win of the Premier League season to come in their seventh game against Bournemouth last weekend. The loss of reigning Player of the Year Steven N’Zonzi has been as sorely felt as it was widely disregarded in the summer, while Ryan Shawcross’ absence has been a critical blow. Although Jack Butland has been a more than able deputy, Asmir Begovic’s departure for Chelsea means  ty le keo bong da anh  Stoke lost their three best players of the last three seasons in one summer. Looking at the competition, ‘Barca B’ will do well to finish mid-table again.

  38. Daniel Sturridge. ca cuoc the thao truc tuyen With his double strike in the 3-2 win over Aston Villa taking him to 37 goals in 57 starts (that’s 0.65 goals per game), Sturridge is officially Liverpool’s most prolific scorer in the Premier League era. That’s ti le da banh not bad when you’re going up against the likes of Luis Suarez (0.63) and Fernando Torres (0.64). ty le ca cuoc bong da truc tuyen At any level of football, strikers can mask a multitude of sins (e.g. conceding twice at home to Villa) and t? l? bóng ?á ngày hôm nay the England frontman is the one who can do it for Brendan Rodgers. The good news for Liverpool is that, after numerous injury lay-offs, their deadliest striker of the modern era is currently alive and well and ty le ca cuoc bong da anh truc tuyen scoring. For now.

  39. Please do ca cuoc truc tuyen bong da the noble thing and f*ck right off! Every time he does ty le soi keo bong da that stupid clapping thing I wish I could put his head between my hands and clap some sense into him tai khoan ca cuoc bong da.