Signs the War Ought to be Reconsidered…

John Glaser, January 11, 2012

This video appears to show four Marines laughing while they urinate on Afghan corpses. One of them jokingly says “Have a great day, buddy.”

Warning: Graphic

The individual who uploaded the YouTube video, which is becoming viral, is not known and the details in the caption that individual provided cannot be independently confirmed. The caption reads: “scout sniper team 4 with 3rd battalion 2nd marines out of camp lejeune peeing on dead talibans.” Whether or not the corpses are Afghan civilians or actual insurgents cannot be verified either.

Capt. Kendra N. Hardesty, a Marine Corps spokesman, said officials would “fully investigate” the incident. “The actions portrayed are not consistent with our core values,” she said in a statement, “and are not indicative of the character of the Marines in our Corps.” My question is, when is the promise to fully investigate such wretchedness finally not going to be enough for the American people?

When disgusting photographs of smiling U.S. soldiers proudly standing next to dead Abu Ghraib detainees were released, Americans were basically told to hide their eyes, buy their yellow ribbon bumper stickers and rest assured the incident would be investigated. When news broke of Manadel al-Jamadi, the Abu Ghraib prisoner who in 2003 was hung from his arms twisted behind his back, beaten, and tortured to death at the hands of U.S. interrogators, Americans were told this was the exception and that the war is still just. When the 5th Stryker Brigade in Kandahar – aka “Kill Team” – slaughtered Afghan children for the fun of it, took celebratory pictures next to their corpses, and mutilated their bodies for evidence of their trophy kill, again Americans were expected to buy into the “bad apple” excuse and forge ahead with the support our troops mantra. When American troops forced Afghan civilians to march ahead of them on roads believed to have been filled with bombs and landmines planted by insurgents, Americans were told it would be investigated and promptly looked away.

The point is not that every single U.S. soldier is the type to urinate on the faces of the dead or hunt Afghan children for sport. Rather, the point is that war invades and contaminates the humanity of individuals. And the context of war abroad while Americans sit safely at home pressures people to ignore its brutality in favor of “patriotism.”

The abuses borne on a daily basis by Afghans, and the embarrassment of being militarily dominated as they’ve been, exceed the imaginations of ordinary Americans. There are a million reasons the war in Afghanistan should end tomorrow. But, generally speaking, when people are at the point that they can make fun out of urinating on mangled bloody corpses, it’s about time for some reconsideration.




16 Responses to “Signs the War Ought to be Reconsidered…”

  1. Another example of Amerikan execptionalism.

    Bushtard was right, freedumb is on the march.

  2. Can't think of the right term, but isn't defacing or mutilating war dead a crime?..

  3. Other countries soldiers might do the same things but their leaders don’t say “just a bad apple” or “it’s not like our values” EVERYTIME something comes out, I watched YouTube vids during the Iraq war that made me puke & pissed me off, then I looked up U.S. War crimes in history & now I’m not shocked or dumbfounded by this behavior.

  4. I believe that desecrating a body is a war crime. As spelled out in the Geneva Convention. Anyone know for certain? Been a while since I've browsed the old GC. Oh crap, I hate homework…

  5. Full Investigation? That's nice, although I doubt the Afghans will give two sh-ts about it. To them, they've already been martyred and are in a better place. The only ones being desecrated here are the Americans who behave in this fashion. Nothing they can do to those Afghans will bring them down to their level.

  6. I predict a thorough investigation — of YouTube and the uploader.

  7. I get the feeling Americans are going to need to be on the receiving end of some of this treatment before they remember why it's wrong. A terrible and painful way to be returned to one's humanity, but apparently that's what it takes for some people to learn how to live with others.

  8. However could this happen? Doesn't the US government constantly remind of us of the fundamental humanity of the Muslim world. When we talk about war deaths don't we always include Afghans and Iraqis?
    Must just be a few bad apples.

  9. EXACTLY! Amerika isn't going to be brought back into the realm of civilized humanity any other way.

  10. Predication: One or more of these sick, murderous f***tards are going to be wearing "law enforcement" uniforms, badges, and weapons within a few years of returning stateside.

  11. Make that "Prediction"

  12. This sort of behavior doesn't surprise me. Check out the remarks on MSNBC regarding Bradley Manning and see just how bloodthirsty, intolerant and fascist Americans are: http://usnews.msnbc.msn.com/_news/2012/01/12/1014

  13. [...] said as much when this video first broke out. See here and here for my previous discussions on it. Print This | var addthis_pub="wiredispatch"; var [...]

  14. you know its a planet fulla retarded monkeys when tomahawks and drones elicit less outrage than urine

  15. [...] arrests have been made less than a week after an internet video surfaced of U.S. Marines urinating on dead Afghan bodies, an incident which the U.S. authorities also claimed it to be investigating. Local Afghans were [...]

  16. [...] arrests have been made less than a week after an internet video surfaced of U.S. Marines urinating on dead Afghan bodies, an incident which the U.S. authorities also claimed it to be investigating. Local Afghans were [...]