Syria’s Disproportionate Conflict and the Pretext to Intervene

John Glaser, May 31, 2012

The aspect of the Syria issue that is getting the most attention right now has the least to do with calls for intervention. I wouldn’t for a second belittle the suffering people there have faced; what I’m saying is that those demanding that America do something about that suffering, apparently care very little about it.

I’ve written previously about how strangely open many of these interventionists are about what an intervention in Syria would mean. Before Rick Santorum dropped out of the presidential race, his Syria talking point was the following: “Syria is a puppet state of Iran. They are a threat not just to Israel, but they have been a complete destabilizing force within Lebanon, which is another problem for Israel, and Hezbollah.” And Romney: “The key ally of Iran, Syria, has a leader that’s in real trouble. And we ought to grab a hold of that like it’s the best thing we’ve ever seen.”

Rep. Marco Rubio (R-FL), who is rumored to be one of Romney’s choices for VP, said recently in a video message to his constituents that arming and aiding the Syrian opposition is “in our national security interest” because “Iran,” which he described as “the number one immediate threat facing the world and the United States,” has “no stronger ally in the world than Syria” and “the loss of the Assad regime in Syria is the single, most damaging thing that can happen to Iran’s regime.”

This is nothing new. But the narrative about a humanitarian catastrophe in Syria obligating the U.S. to intervene on behalf of innocent civilians is still the dominant one. In the headlines of the major newspapers and on network news, the suffering of the Syrian people is prompting calls to “do something” to “stop this,” and so on. But the suffering going on in Syria – as horrendous as it is – is only as prominent in our news media and political debate because of the geopolitics.

I was struck by a segment on MSNBC’s Morning Joe wherein former National Security advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski faced off against a chorus of Syria interventionists. Brzezinski was being eminently reasonable in arguing against intervention in Syria and against using the conflict to justify being a belligerent bully on the world stage – particularly towards Russia. Then he said that the conflict “is not as horrible or as dramatic as it is portrayed,” especially when compared to other recent conflicts around the world, like “the horrible war in Sri Lanka, the killings in Rwanda, the deaths in Libya and so forth – you know, let’s have a sense of proportion here.” He added, “Let’s not exaggerate this conflict…Look, I think what we are hearing is a lot of hand-wringing and hysteria…”

It’s an important point. To watch American media and listen to haranguing politicians right now, you’d think Syria was the worst hell-hole in the world. It’s bad (as I said above, I would never belittle it), but something like 800,000 people were murdered in Rwanda in the 1990s and we heard very little about intervention there. The civil war in Sri Lanka lasted for over two decades and led to 100,000 or so violent deaths, ending in a shaky resolution only in 2009. I can’t agree with Brzezinski about Libya, but consider the Sudan. There was something on the order of 400,000 civilians dead in the Darfur conflict, again only petering out in very recent years, while the conflict largely persists. In March 2011, a civil war in the Ivory Coast broke out with incredible massacres of civilians, but I’d bet Rubio couldn’t find it on a map, much less argue for intervention.

People like McCain and Romney and John Kerry and the other powerful people in Congress calling for more direct intervention in Syria like to present themselves as being genuinely concerned with the suffering of their fellow man. But that is evidently not the case. Syria is strategically located in the Middle East, is geographically a close neighbor of Israel and a close ally of Iran. President Bashar al-Assad is a puppet of the Russians who value their last close ally in the region because it affords them geo-political influence and a chance to defy U.S. imperialism. And this is why the conflict in Syria is being portrayed as disproportionately grave. And this is why pundits and politicos are calling for intervention. The conflict is merely a pretext.

[Luckily, the Obama administration has been able to perceive the costs of intervention and so have stated opposition to military action. Still, they have provided elements of the opposition with both lethal and non-lethal aid, which is probably helping to prolong the conflict.]

Here is the MSNBC segment:




39 Responses to “Syria’s Disproportionate Conflict and the Pretext to Intervene”

  1. I wonder if Iran's deployed their female ninja assassins to Syria…

  2. Assad is a client of the Russians, not their puppet.

    Of course it is a pretext, if US were concerned about human rights violations it would first cease its own.

  3. Absolutely correct, Karl!

  4. Hurrr.

    I would like to see Euroweasels agree to a NATO intervention while Russia is a major energy provider for the landmass. No natural gas for you, chaps. You may want to import from Iran or Lybia. Especially now that the Germans basically dumped several GW off their net due to politically motivated closure of perfectly serviceable nuclear reactors.

  5. Always remember that the US government (and its sycophants) doesn't give a flyin' fsck about ordinary US citizens, let alone foreigners. The only exception is when it is politically expedient to appear to do so. The US government only cares about power, privilege and position.

    Albright's statement that the death of 500,00 Iraqis was ' a price worth paying' is a good example.

  6. Hi I like your blog. Do you want to visitor publish in mine at some point? In that case you should inform me by means of e-mail or just reply to this particular comment because I subscribed to announcements and will realize should you.

  7. [...] But Russia’s threat of a veto is at least blocking another Western war in the Middle East and marginalizing somewhat the very transparent calls for U.S. intervention which are being made by hawks who want to stick it to Iran as opposed to save the Syrian people. [...]

  8. [...] But Russia’s threat of a veto is at least blocking another Western war in the Middle East and marginalizing somewhat the very transparent calls for U.S. intervention which are being made by hawks who want to stick it to Iran as opposed to save the Syrian people. [...]

  9. [...] they are all-knowing and all-powerful enough to craft and mold a particular outcome pursuant to their unscrupulous interests, but they have the hubris to disregard the possible consequences their interventions may breed far [...]

  10. I would like to apI feel great to write this article, which share a lot of things, I learned a lot of knowledge from which to learn more things.

  11. Thank you for another essential article. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a complete way of writing ? I have a presentation incoming week, and I am on the lookout for such information.

  12. It was really a great time to comment on such blogs.

  13. You completed certain excellent points there. I did a search on the topic and identified the majority of people will consent along with your weblog.

  14. Amazing post thanks for sharing

  15. Thanks for sharing this informative blog with us..
    IT Consultants
    IT Support Melbourne
    IT Services Melbourne
    Business IT Services

  16. I’m actually delighted that I can buoy interpret them.I book binding you! A very worthy article, the article highlights many of the commendable!resume writers reviews

  17. The key ally of Asian country, Syria, incorporates a leader that’s in real hassle. and that we need to grab a hold of that like it’s the simplest factor we’ve ever seen. statistical analysis services

  18. I am often to blogging and i really recognize your content. I love your post too much. i think you are a person, I hope you can continue to work.

  19. Excellent post.The post is written in very a good manner and it entails many useful information for me. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post
    english grammer check

  20. I think it really takes very little time to understand that what is going on is an attempt to use censorship as a means of influencing public opinion, by silencing your critics and enabling or empowering those who present the party line, said Scott Horton, a human rights lawyer and Harpers blogger.houston winter limo

  21. One of the biggest challenges that face anyone is justifying what one want to do and why it's going to disrupt the status quo — whether it be to give opinion or starting a converstaion. It really helps when reading your material insisted on the matter you have highlighted. Fine tunning the concept you discussed will surely bring new opportunities in this area of interest and brings will result something positive. I appreciate your efforts of taking notice of above discussed matter.

  22. What a lovely writing piece. Really useful info. I am really happy to come across a bulk of such a great written stuff. Thanks

  23. breast augmentation in orange county
    Very good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which we all need.

  24. A real informative blog like this is an exceptionally cool helping resource for a needy information seeker like me! Thanks a lot…

  25. a list to know a few of them and where they can be found..

  26. Very nice post. I like it very much. It is very helpful for me and my friends.

  27. It's gracefull to see what i was searching for. That's the material which I was searching about. The matter you've highlighted above is surely valueable for anyone to workout. the concept of your article is very true and It will result in a positive way. Thanks you very much for sharing this with us.
    swarovski clutch

  28. This is a really quality post.I find this information through Google Search engine. I read your Article very carefully it is really. glow poi

  29. Fully a fantastic document. A person performed any wonderful job. Appreciate it for carrying this desire connected with previous evaluated concept. Were pleased that people found types document plus the data you speak about in the document inside is excellent. These records they might be helpful for people who. Keep your very good do the job going.

  30. I have been planning to buy one so that I can take my family on fishing trips on the weekends. I hope that I do not get looted in the process!
    writing illusion<a/>

  31. I was so lucky to visit this site I really want to recommend this to everyone cause there is no doubt about its content I really love this one thanks for sharing this!
    writing HQ<a/>

  32. An Attractive article on information like this is a great find. It’s like verdict a treasure. I am grateful for how you articulate your many points and share in your own views. Thank a lot for sharing such an informatics thing.
    how to write personal statement<a/>

  33. Nice blog, it’s truly inspiring to read such a brilliant piece of work. I felt I was in another world while I read through your post. I hope to read some more stimulating stuff on your blog again. Thanks
    how to write well<a/>

  34. I never found such a great and amazing content and fabulous solution to my problem…….really giving a different idea in applying ideas in planning a systematic way. thank you !
    dissertation writing information<a/>

  35. I have found this article very exciting. Do you have any others on this topic? I am also sending it to my friend to enjoy your writing style. Thanks

  36. Mayday is The Club's specialist UK breakdown & recovery scheme, providing 24-hour cover, 365 days a year, whether you're towing or not.

  37. An Eye-catching weblog on details like this is a fantastic discover. It’s like judgment a value. I am thankful for how you communicate your many factors and discuss in your own opinions. Thank a lot for discussing such an informatics factor.

  38. It so hard to find such good articles on dictatorship. This was really informative and satisfying. Thank you, please do keep writing such great articles.

  39. Aw, this was an extremely good post. I have Spend some time and actual effort to make a great article
    is appearing in the article… but what can I say… I put things off a whole lot and never seem to get
    nearly anything done.