Precision Propaganda

John Glaser, July 03, 2012

At the Aspen Ideas Festival last week, retired/fired General Stanley McChrystal gave a ringing endorsement of drone warfare, only to subsequently mention, footnote-style, that the so-called precision bombing of drones don’t always spare civilians. ”We should be using drones a lot,” he said. But “We need to understand what drones are not.”

The Atlantic’s John Hudson:

[McChrystal] described a chilling account of the wrongful execution of a civilan farmer in Afghanistan by a U.S. drone strike. “We fired a missile and killed him and found out he was a farmer,” McChrystal said. After the assassination, McChystal replayed the event to Afghan President Hamid Karzai on a laptop who told McChystal the farmer was engaged in routine irrigation work just prior to the missile strike–an activity the U.S. military should’ve been familiar with. “You have to know these sorts of things,” McChrystal told the crowd.

A loose-lipped general is an enlightening thing. Remember, McChrystal also explained matter-of-factly to the New York Times how the US military “have shot an amazing number of people [in Afghanistan], but to my knowledge, none has ever proven to be a threat.” He also, rather adroitly, explained the logic of what he called “insurgent math.” That is, “for every innocent person you kill, you create 10 new enemies.”

The talk of drones being “precise” is mostly ideological. The term is used as if it isn’t inherently relative, but it must be. Relative to an atom bomb, drones are “precise.” Relative to a sniper rifle, drones are…what?

The state and the military always claim their weapons are precise. In WWII, the US parted with the British in their night time carpet bombings of civilian areas. New technology, they said, made it possible to do “precision bombing.” The Norden bombsight, which could calculate the bomb’s trajectory for accuracy, was said to have been able to hit a pickle barrel from 30,000 feet.

But “in reality,” writes Yuki Tanaka in Bombing Civilians: A Twentieth-Century History, “‘precision bombing’ was a euphemism, as the bombs regularly fell at least a quarter mile from the target.” The US Strategic Bombing Survey, issued in September 1945 concluded that “in the over-all, only about 20% of the bombs aimed at precision targets fell within this target area.”

The propaganda about our military being humanitarian and our bombs being precise is the same now as it was then. The reason the dogma about the “precision” of drones is so widespread throughout the public, is because not enough US generals make a point to mention the mistaken killings of civilian farmers in rural Afghanistan.




14 Responses to “Precision Propaganda”

  1. Great piece, John! Thanks for putting this on everybody's radar.

  2. My own mother, who lived in what later became known as East Germany, told me how after some of the allied bombing, the kids found unexploded ordinance! She never got close enough to one but told me that some kids did get killed for playing around one. How's that for "precision"?

  3. It's not like the government crushed their testicles to get their parents to talk…now THAT'S precision…

  4. The US Army is worse than the Nazis, worse than SS and Gestapo; in Iraq they kidnapped small boys and their mothers, then raped the boys and forced their mothers to watch while it was filmed by a female soldier. Some experiment ? And birth defects are worse in Fallujah than they were in Hiroshima because of The Great Satan´s depleted uranium weapons. Another experiment ? They are sick bastards in the CIA/Pentagon.

  5. Yes, cruelty, arrogance and ignorance riched nearly level as most cruel army – IDF of Israel. Partnership in crimes against humanity , duo US and Israel remains leader…peter czech

  6. Yes, but dead is dead and I thought the topic was about precision bombing not precision nut crushing.

  7. “we fired a missile, blew up this human being, turns out he was a farmer”, “the soldier who fired the missile is with his family & kids enjoying life” – Every drone strike ever….

  8. McChystal the farmer was engaged in routine irrigation work just prior to the missile strike–an activity the U.S. military should’ve been familiar with. “You have to know these sorts of things,” McChrystal told the crowd.

  9. [...] this report helped prove it further. And as Hakim says, civilian casualties happen very frequently, contrary to propaganda about drones being precision weapons, but are just never [...]

  10. What is the exactly decision of that propaganda.Please share me.I hope. we will get more update and helps in the solutions of this.

  11. Precision propaganda is difficult to manage.I hope, I can get the meaning of this.Please share more info.like this.If you have please update me.

  12. Every one well known about the Precision Propaganda.It's good to know about this.Please let me know, what is the next information…

  13. Aw, this was an extremely good post. I have Spend some time and actual effort to make a great article is appearing in the article… but what can I say… I put things off a whole lot and never seem to get nearly anything done

  14. very nice news araba ilan? ver