Does Wolfowitz Actually Believe US Proxy War in Syria Will Bring Democracy?
Paul Wolfowitz, sort of the Don of neoconservatism, still believes US aggression in the Middle East can proliferate democracy:
Wolfowitz just lets the question about post-war chaos and sectarianism wash over him. Iraq and Syria are different, he says. Actually, they’re quite similar.The sectarian make-up of the country is similar, the fact that Sunni extremists have swarmed into the country to exploit the conflict is similar to what happened in Iraq. The regime is a secular-nationalist, Shiite-minority Baathist dictatorship, whereas Iraq had a secular-nationalist, Sunni-minority Baathist dictatorship. One difference is that there was some structure of potential leadership, however nefarious, in Iraq’s opposition, post-Saddam. In Syria, that is not the case. But this difference only makes a descent into bloody sectarian civil war more likely, not less. And his comment about there not being US forces on the ground – well, whoop-dee-doo, but doesn’t this argument contradict the neoconservative claim that a surge in US forces was the policy which stabilized the civil war?
The Washington Post reports on his remarks:
“Syria is going to be governed by Syrians, and I don’t see why people are so comfortable saying we shouldn’t be arming them, but it’s okay for Islamic, Islamist governments in the Persian Gulf that don’t share our objectives — it’s okay for them to be arming them,” said Wolfowitz, alluding to reports that Iran continues to send arms to Syria.
“I think trying to shape the political agenda of that future Syrian government is very important,” he said.
Uh, I think the Post got this all wrong. It’s pretty clear to me that Wolfowitz was not referring to Iran’s support of the Assad regime. Instead, he seems to be saying that we should be arming the Syrian rebels to beat the Saudis and the Qataris to the punch and “shape the political agenda of that future Syria” towards democracy as opposed to Sunni monarchy, or some satellite regime thereof. I think Wolfowitz is the honest type of neoconservative interventionist. It seems he truly does believe we should be going to war in the Middle East to export democracy, as opposed to installing successor regimes equally horrible as their predecessors, just more in line with Washington’s demands. This honesty (read: stupidity) allows him to criticize the venerable US allies in Saudi Arabia the Gulf states, with whom Washington is cooperating to support the rebel militias. Elected officials still refuse to do so, leading to contradictions like the one pointed out by Robert Fisk yesterday:
President Barack Obama and his Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, say they want a democracy in Syria. But Qatar is an autocracy and Saudi Arabia is among the most pernicious of caliphate-kingly-dictatorships in the Arab world. Rulers of both states inherit power from their families – just as Bashar has done – and Saudi Arabia is an ally of the Salafist-Wahabi rebels in Syria, just as it was the most fervent supporter of the medieval Taliban during Afghanistan’s dark ages.
Even on his own terms, experts disagree with Wolfowitz (not that it matters to his impenetrable dogmatism). For one thing, the militias he is arguing for sending weapons to are largely anathema to “democracy.” UN rights chief Navi Pillay last month condemned the continued flow of weapons from foreign powers to both sides in the Syrian conflict. “The ongoing provision of arms to the Syrian government and to its opponents feeds additional violence,” she said. “Any further militarization of the conflict must be avoided at all costs.”
Marc Lynch, a Middle East expert at George Washington University who has actually consulted the Obama administration on the issue, agrees that arming the rebels lacks foresight and will worsen the conflict.
A recent study out of Brandeis University concluded “the distillation of historical experience with civil war and insurgency, along with a sober reckoning of conditions on the ground in Syria, make clear” that arming the rebels is “likely to amplify the harm that it seeks to eliminate by prolonging a hurting stalemate.”
Winston Smith
July 30th, 2012 at 11:45 am
Apparantly so !!! The same delusional behaviour prevails here in Britain, as William Haue the foreign secretary reularly makes similar statements.
They appear to believe the Wahabist Jihadists can be put back in the box when they have achieved the objective western polcty makers want, as in Bosnia-Hercegovina where er… many still live with the local women who were forced into marriages with them, and Afghanistan where er… we are fighting a second war with their successors.
But Paul Wolfowitz is a Neo-Con, he can't believe this. He wants chaos in the country. It was the Neo-Cons who drew up the Clean Break 1996 plan for Bennie Netanyahu and the most extreme political faction to confrount the Arab states, the Palestinians and cause chaos in Syria thus avoiding a 2 State Solution.
JLS
July 30th, 2012 at 12:06 pm
I guess just minding our own business is once again, totally out of the question?
iUniverse
July 30th, 2012 at 11:33 pm
Many thanks regarding giving everybody a really usually so great plus filled with a good time for me personally as well as my business office friends to search your website practically 3 times weekly to review the most recent takes you could have.
curmudgeonvt
July 31st, 2012 at 5:39 am
Bingo!!!!! Give the man a Kewpie!!
JoaoAlfaiate
August 1st, 2012 at 8:54 am
Guess we're preparing to work our magic in Syria and Iran, just like in Iraq and Palestine.
the book of souls
August 1st, 2012 at 11:30 am
Simply wish to say your article is as astonishing. The clearness in your
post is simply excellent and i can assume you are an
expert on this subject. Fine with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep
up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on
the enjoyable work.
tahsin halabi
August 1st, 2012 at 1:29 pm
Tahsin Halabi a Palestinian poet
Damascus –August-2-2012
I wonder why most analysts and political figures are calling for foreign military intervention against the Syrian regime and avoid calling for a dialogue between the opposition parties and the regime ?Is not such a call good enough to stop bloodshed that both involved in?Everyone knows now about the military operations the rebel armed groups launching in Syria against all Syrians employees in the official services and not only against the uniforms .Maybe you do not know that some local residents have been killed publicly in the streets by the insurgents just because they expressed different opinion, is this the democracy that you support ?Do you know that many armed insurgents on the spot used to call for the termination of everyone belong to the Allawi community the Sheit and the Druse communities considering them nonmuslims !? Is it a special democracy made only for such concept of Islam ?No one can ignore that there are lot of anti Assad regime among many western governments ,but however no one should agree to support such middle ages sectarian war even if it will lead to the breakdown of the regime !
Delana
August 3rd, 2012 at 2:59 am
Bennie Netanyahu and the most extreme political faction to confrount the Arab states, the Palestinians and cause chaos in Syria thus avoiding a 2 State Solution.
Rebbecca
August 9th, 2012 at 12:08 am
Paul Wolfowitz, sort of the Don of neoconservatism, still believes US aggression in the Middle East can proliferate democracy:
josef
December 7th, 2012 at 12:52 am
well, Shea Butter have some special medicinal properties too aside from cosmetic applications*
ralph lauren en soldes
matildahorner
February 12th, 2013 at 6:48 pm
Running a country using the democracy is a difficult thing to do if there is still a lot of opposition in the country. You should seek agreement first.family guy online
company registration
February 20th, 2013 at 3:53 pm
Sommige dingen zijn gerekend tot de display, snelheid van de service na de verkoop follow-up, technische vaardigheden, hoe je telefoon en ga zo maar door af te handelen. De resultaten van het onderzoek zullen worden gebruikt als een evaluatie van de kwaliteit van de dienstverlening uw bedrijf.
company registration
CharlesKei
March 4th, 2013 at 11:12 am
Democracy is done in many ways that will either produce something good. You have to do a lot of ways to be able to make a good result in the current process.labrador puppies for sale
Casino Theme
March 4th, 2013 at 1:03 pm
Teine asi väärib märkimist, et kulutada raha turunduse raisku, kui sa ei suuda mida kliendid tahavad ja ootavad. Olen alati küsida ettevõtete omanikud hoolikalt kaaluda enne, kui hakkate turustamise oma äri, et tagada, et nad saaksid vastata klientide ootustele.
Casino Theme
Glock Barrel
March 12th, 2013 at 3:28 pm
Ta?iau, ar ne manote, kad tur?t? b?ti rinkodaros biudžet? milijardus doleri?, ir tada b?t? galima pasiekti rezultat?. Yra t?kstan?iai maž? ?moni?, kurie reklamuoti protingai su labai minimaliomis s?naudomis.
Glock Barrel
California Fishing
March 22nd, 2013 at 5:29 am
Des idées de marketing est essentiel pour le succès, mais je crois aussi que la bonne attitude déterminera en grande partie le succès lui-même. Je suis très heureux que ce jour a travaillé avec tant d'entreprises très prospères.
California Fishing
Robot Vacuum
March 23rd, 2013 at 6:42 pm
Democracy is a lot to do and desired by many citizens. You can do a good role to get involved in building your country's course.
WandaSam
April 4th, 2013 at 8:51 pm
War has become one of the things that can make the situation uncomfortable place to live. Therefore, the government should be able to think more clearly when deciding to go to war because it can have a negative impact on the social life of the community. WaterlessUrinalCartridges.net
RayKazama
April 8th, 2013 at 8:12 pm
Democracy is one thing that many fought for by many people. But in fact there are not many people who understand that this is something that requires hard work.product photographer long island
Corals At Keppel Bay
April 26th, 2013 at 8:04 am
Great website. Lots of useful information here. I am sending it to a few friends ans additionally sharing in delicious. And naturally, thank you to your sweat!
Corals
April 26th, 2013 at 8:07 am
Democracy is done in many ways that will either produce something good. You have to do a lot of ways to be able to make a good result in the current process. Corals At Keppel Bay
cheap sunglasses
May 4th, 2013 at 8:15 pm
Iran-Contra do over cha-cha! Where are you Oliver North, the Obama needs you.
"High crimes and murderous treason are, at times, necessary to protect Caesa