‘Israel is not going to attack Iran’

John Glaser, August 02, 2012

Journalist Larry Derfner says it plainly: “Israel is not going to attack Iran.”

Not before the November 6 presidential election, not afterward if Obama wins, and maybe not afterward even if Romney wins, which is unlikely.

It’s not that Netanyahu doesn’t want to bomb Iran – he does, and he makes that clearer every day. What’s happened is that there’s been such a torrent of opposition in the Israeli media this week from the security establishment, starting with IDF chief Benny Gantz, and backed by the Obama Administration and Pentagon, that there’s no way Bibi can get his cabinet to vote for a war, and without the cabinet’s backing, he can’t do it. The ministers will not support Bibi in an extremely risky war opposed by the heads of the IDF, IDF Intelligence, the Air Force, the Mossad, the Shin Bet and the United States of America.

The military establishment in the United States and Israel have been pretty strongly against launching a war on Iran. In Israel, everyone from the former head of the Israeli intelligence agency Mossad Meir Dagan, to current head of the Mossad Tamir Pardo, Israel’s military chief Benny Gantz, former prime minister Ehud Olmert, former leader of the Kadima party Tzipi Livni, and internal security chief Yuval Diskin, have come out to push back against Netanyahu. Broadly speaking, they argue that Iran is not developing nuclear weapons, that Iran doesn’t present an existential threat, and that war is not the appropriate answer.

Those pushing for war are a relatively small but extremely influential group of politicians and foreign policy analysts. But since the costs of an unnecessary war are hard to deny – as is the fact that it’s even more likely to produce a nuclear Iran – these habitual interventionists will find other ways. Already, Foreign Affairs is running essays by raving necons like Michael Ledeen, who is arguing for Washington to foment internal revolution to change the regime in Iran…because, you know, that worked out so well last time.




  • mojo

    If that happens, US and England needs to attack Israel.., after all it is their abused child so they need to say NO once and for all.

  • http://whatdirectdemocracymightbe.wordpress.com/ Daryl Davis

    It seems quite obvious that Israel and the U.S. have already begun a cyber war against Iran. No telling what other operations are underway. Conventional airstrikes may be both ineffective and unnecessary against underground nuclear facilities.

    Could they tunnel right to them? Who knows? Unless you're a higher-up in the military, don't embarrass yourself by trying to answer that question. The only other question is: Will Valerie Jarrett approve of it?
    http://whatdirectdemocracymightbe.wordpress.com/2

  • gmc1987

    You've got to be kidding me. Netanyahu is Hitler. He will get his way, whether theres a vote or not.

  • Nelson_2008

    He doesn't have to attack Iran to get a war against Iran started. He merely has to get one of the Western puppet governments to attack Syria, that's all.

  • MoT

    There are times you wonder if sanity has slipped its moorings and set sail for war based on the comments I've seen elsewhere. Then there are the vast number of rational, very much awake, people voicing their anger at these lunatics beating the drums to do so. Back before the Afghan and Iraq debacles they rode on the coat tails of emotionalism over 9-11 and what I'm concerned about is that it will be yet another bit of staged theatrics, on just as grandiose a scale, with the usual actors, that will tip the scales of idiocy once more.

  • Macroman

    Enter false flag attack…

  • Goldhoarder

    Is Antiwar this stupid? The war already started. Everyone forget Syria?

  • Jamal

    Feisty little Japan attacked much larger United States 70 years ago, attempting a small "surgical" strike. Israel should look very closely at what happened. Japan ended up having a new government system forced on them.

    I know it sounds unbelievable to arrogant Westerners, but the same thing would very likely be the outcome of any attack by Israel on Iran. The best case scenario for Israel would be a humiliating stalemate after about a decade, just like the Iran Iraq war.

  • Rico

    An attck in Iran would bring about the closure of the straight of Hormuz, the destruction of storage infrastructure along the gulf, the most likely destruction of other oil related Saudi oil infrastructure and maybe others like Kuwait. A logical response to the economic war and sanctions already in place against Iran by the west.

    End result barrel of oil at $300…minimun some estimate up to $500.00 per barrel for what about at least a year or two.

    This translates into a 500% increase in the cost of food (at the production level) worldwide, look for a billion or so deaths by starvation alone. A stated and admitted goal of the evil doers for a long time.
    Thres more than a nuclear Iran at stake here, it is the comming of the messiah (anti christ) that Israel (zionist) and the freemasons are pushing for…

  • http://www.hostertalk.com More

    I just hate war anywhere!

  • goldhoarder

    This is complete BS. I love you guys but you are lost at sea on this Glaser. If they get the Syrian Government overthrown war on Iran is automatic. Iraq and Libya are great success stories as far as the USA elite is concerned. These worthless brown skinned oxygen wasters need to die… as long as we keep killing them and creating chaos how it turns out in the end isn't important…our masters have figured out that having stateless governments isn't such a bad thing after all… as long as the middle east doesn't band together to kick our evil a$$es out we will continue our oppress our subhuman subjects.

    • Deep_Thinker

      "These worthless brown skinned oxygen wasters need to die" – Who are you to judge anothers worth?

      Also, the USA doesn't have the ability to sustain a war against Iran. Iraq was not a success story, and the same with Afghanistan. The US is running with their tails between their legs now that they have figured out you cannot defeat people that do not want a democracy set up in their country.

  • Pingback: theCL Report: The Role of the Sucker()

  • Pingback: Why do people keep predicting war with Iran? : The Iran Project()

  • Pingback: Israel Beefs Up Military Readiness -- News from Antiwar.com()

  • Pingback: Why do people keep predicting war with Iran? « Attack the System()

  • Pingback: Israel Beefs Up Military Readiness «()

  • Pingback: Is a war with Iran imminent? « LobeLog.com()

  • Pingback: Is a war with Iran imminent? | IPS Writers in the Blogosphere()

  • Pingback: Is an Israeli attack on Iran imminent? | IPS Writers in the Blogosphere()

  • Pingback: Iran’s Nuclear Program Merely a Pretext « Antiwar.com Blog()

  • Pingback: ‘Ya Know Who’s Messianic? Netanyahu.’ « Antiwar.com Blog()

  • http://blackops2hacks.wordpress.com/ black ops 2 pc hacks

    Hey, people used to write excellent, but the last several posts have been somewhat boringâ?¦ I miss your great writings. Past several posts are just a little out of track! come on!

  • http://www.arganio.com Argan Oil

    Conventional airstrikes may be both ineffective and unnecessary against underground nuclear facilities.

  • http://www.loverhost.co.uk larzze

    A logical response to the economic war and sanctions already in place against Iran by the west. internet marketing Florida

  • seharpro

    Great post. I must say thanks for the information. Education is definitely a sticky subject. However, is still among the leading topics of our time. I appreciate your post and look forward to more.
    Get more followers

  • zishami8

    Then there are the vast number of rational, very much awake, people voicing their anger at these lunatics beating the drums to do so. LA Fashion

  • zishami8

    You've got to be kidding me. Netanyahu is Hitler. He will get his way, whether theres a vote or not.hot girls

  • http://www.hqviews.com buy youtube views

    The best case scenario for Israel would be a humiliating stalemate after about a decade, just like the Iran Iraq war.

  • http://www.tubidy.gen.tr tubidy

    I'm not going to lie, I'm really impressed. Its rare for me to find something on the internet that's as entertaining and intriguing as what you've got here.

  • nicole

    The best blog always in th? nh?a serves information regarding products ads

  • nicole

    I continuously livelihood on upcoming to your parcel again retributory in best blog always in th? b?o hành serves information

  • http://www.canvasndecor.com/ canvas printing

    Fantastic blog site you’ve got listed here. It is tricky to find substantial good quality producing like yours currently. I truly enjoy persons such as you! Get care!!

  • zishami8

    Fantastic blog site you’ve got listed here.It is tricky to find substantial good quality producing like yours currently. I truly enjoy persons such as you! Get care!!How to remove skin tags

  • http://www.canvasndecor.com/ canvas prints

    Broadly speaking, they argue that Iran is not developing nuclear weapons, that Iran doesn’t present an existential threat, and that war is not the appropriate answer.

  • zishami8

    A logical response to the economic war and sanctions already in place against Iran by the west. Terry, Simon and Kelly PLLC

  • http://www.gramcentre.com/buy-instagram-likes/ Buy Instagram Likes

    I am new to blogging, and I enjoyed reading your blog so much! It helped me get inspired to be consistent with it and you mentioned quite a few GREAT tips that I am going to apply in my future blogs.

  • zishami8

    Israel will be destroyed even if they think to attack on Iran. cheap clothing stores Iran have much more strong and powerful nuclear power.

  • cara

    War, yes war, it is all about destruction and annihilation of humanity. War divides, war burns houses and people. Download the history of the world that in war no country, no community wins. But, still we fight. War Horse is a heart wrenching tale of courage and friendship.
    how to get comments on instagram

  • http://www.gramcentre.com/buy-instagram-likes/ chocodat

    Pretty! This has been an incredibly wonderful post. Thanks for supplying this information.

    Buy Instagram Likes
    Buy keek Likes

  • http://www.gramcentre.com/buy-instagram-like-spread/ Andie May

    Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include.Great site, keep it up!
    *_* MY PAGE *_*

    Buy Instagram Likespread || Buy keek Package

  • Alex Edward

    Your post is quite impressive
    Skyfall Suit Repllica