ACLU Takes CIA to Court Over Secret Drone War Everybody Knows About

John Glaser, September 19, 2012

The Obama administration has a good thing going. They get to run a futuristic drone war that operates above the law and allows them to bomb people outside any official theater of conflict, even if they are American citizens with Constitutional rights to due process. When the drone war produces a juicy nugget that is perfect for some jingoistic war propaganda, they get to sing it from the mountaintops. When the press asks them uncomfortable questions about it, however, or when concerned parties file suit against the administration, they get to say the drone program is classified and avoid any public or legal scrutiny.

Tomorrow, the American Civil Liberties Union will be in court with the government, specifically the CIA, over this little scam they’re running. The ACLU has tried to file Freedom of Information Act  requests to get information on the drone program and its legal basis, but the government has said ‘no, it’s secret.’ The ACLU is now returning fire in court, arguing that if administration officials get to selectively talk about the drone war in speeches and to reporters, it can’t then turn around and say the program is too secret to comply with FOIA requests.

“The notion that the CIA’s targeted killing program is a secret is nothing short of absurd,” said ACLU Deputy Legal Director Jameel Jaffer, who will argue the case before a three-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit Appeals Court. “For more than two years, senior officials have been making claims about the program both on the record and off. They’ve claimed that the program is effective, lawful and closely supervised. If they can make these claims, there is no reason why they should not be required to respond to requests under the Freedom of Information Act.”

The Guardian:

The ACLU’s demand for details of the programme – including documents related to its legal justification drawn up by the department of justice – is aimed at prompting a national debate on the scope of the drone programme and how it is used. Its legality is a particular issue. The memorandum justifying the legal basis for the targeted killing has now been requested by at least 10 members of Congress and three different lawsuits but it remains so secret that that acknowledging its existence is a classified matter. “The public has a right to decide for itself whether or not the programme is lawful or moral,” Jaffer said.

I’d be hard pressed to find a more clear-cut case of violating the checks and balances intended in the Constitution. Congress has been sidestepped and ignored. The court’s have been circumvented through absurd and contradictory state secrets privileges. Unfortunately, brave and independent federal judges like Judge Katherine B. Forrest, who tried to block enforcement of the government’s new detention powers in the NDAA, are few and far between. Still, the ACLU has a pretty strong case, so we’ll have to see if the judges in the DC Circuit Appeals Court tomorrow get pressured into granting the Executive Branch the power to skirt all accountability and wage a secret, lawless war.




14 Responses to “ACLU Takes CIA to Court Over Secret Drone War Everybody Knows About”

  1. Some good news once in a while.

  2. Wouldn't it be nice if the ACLU did more of this and less of the nonsense they do, like suing a Rhode Island school over a father-daughter dance?

  3. The drone program may be classified to avoid public and legal scrutiny, but as Jesus clearly stated: "We shall know them through their deeds." The world knows what and who we are, which is why we lose more and more respect and gain more and more hatred. Who do Obama and company think they´re kidding? Certainly not the people in the Middle East. The peoples of the entire world know that there is no justification, legal or moral, in drone attacks. None.

  4. I wonder whose court this will be heard in.

  5. D.C. Circuit Appeals Court

  6. The ACLU is now returning fire in court, arguing that if administration officials get to selectively talk about the drone war in speeches and to reporters, it can’t then turn around and say the program is too secret to comply with FOIA requests.

  7. Nice to read it along with my coffee

  8. [...] of the biggest problems (and there are many) with the Obama administration’s drone program is that it targets unidentified [...]

  9. hi!,I really like your writing so a lot! percentage we keep in touch more approximately your post on AOL? I require a specialist in this space to unravel my problem. Maybe that’s you! Having a look forward to peer you.

  10. The ACLU’s demand for details of the programme – including documents related to its legal justification drawn up by the department of justice – is aimed at prompting a national debate on the scope of the drone programme and how it is used. Its legality is a particular issue. wedding partybus

  11. The tips you provided here are extremely precious. It proved a real pleasurable surprise to own that watching for me while i wakened today. They are constantly to the level and easy to comprehend. Thanks a bunch for any valuable ideas you've got shared listed here.
    Pull ralph lauren

  12. Discussion might call into question about how they do not try to mobilize anybody against the continuation of the US's Middle East wars under Obama.

  13. Greetings from Los angeles! I'm bored at work so I decided to check out your site on my iphone during lunch break. I love the knowledge you provide here and can't wait to take a look when I get home. I'm amazed at how quick your blog loaded on my phone .. I'm not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyhow, superb site!
    mattress reviews

  14. I continuously livelihood on upcoming to your parcel again retributory in containerful you have posted new list.