We’re Not Leaving Afghanistan

John Glaser, October 15, 2012

Politicians technically use the same language as us, but many of their words have very different meanings. In last week’s vice presidential debates, for example, Joe Biden said, “We are leaving [Afghanistan]. We are leaving in 2014, period. Period.” Micah Zenko at the Council on Foreign Relations reminds us how the words “leaving” or “withdrawal” mean something very different in politics:

The full withdrawal of all U.S. troops out of Afghanistan is not the current position of the Obama administration. On October 3, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton announced the appointment of Ambassador James Warlick, deputy special Representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan, to lead the negotiations for an agreement that would keep U.S. troops in Afghanistan for an undefined period of time. Reportedly, “Western officials have mentioned the residual American force as ranging from a few thousand to some 20,000.” In addition, some U.S. policymakers assume that Afghanistan will serve as hub for special operations raids and drone strikes into Pakistan.

Actually, a similar deceit is being peddled about Iraq. The Obama campaign constantly claims that they ended the Iraq war and brought all the troops home. In fact, they tried desperately to keep thousands of troops there, and simply got kicked out – only then deciding to pick up this narrative of ending the occupation.

But even that aside, the claim that “we left” is not true. As Zenko writes, “The United States currently has 225 troops, 530 security assistance team members, and over 4,000 contractors to equip and train Iraqi security forces.” And it’s worth remembering these Iraqi security forces we’re training have essentially been used as a secret police force for the increasingly authoritarian Maliki to attack, detain, and torture his political opponents and crack down harshly on public dissent.

In political campaigns, politicians can talk all they want about a full US withdrawal of Afghanistan. But technocrats have long admitted publicly that there will be no withdrawal. In a talk at the Council on Foreign Relations almost a year ago, under secretary of defense for policy at the Department of Defense Michèle Flournoy, explained that “2014 is not a withdrawal date—it’s an inflection point.” Afghans at that time “are still going to need support from the international community,” she said, and the U.S. has “been negotiating a strategic partnership agreement with the Afghan government that would lay out an enduring strategic partnership far into the future.”

Enduring partnership. Great. Of course a major problem is that so long as any foreign occupation exists in Afghanistan, and so long as any Kabul government is propped up from abroad, the insurgency will remain alive and well. The insurgency has persisted for 11 years despite the efforts of the world’s most advanced military. And all signs tell me they will continue to fight to oust the occupier even after a “withdrawal” (which we now know really only means a smaller occupation).




23 Responses to “We’re Not Leaving Afghanistan”

  1. More of the same old, same old. Only without the media.

    Once in a while some 'expose' will tell the sad tale that things aren't
    any better, just more expensive.

  2. [...] articlesBiden Says ‘Out of Afghanistan in 2014?, Administration Disagrees (pjmedia.com)We’re Not Leaving Afghanistan (antiwar.com) Post Published: 16 October 2012 Author: Ironmill Found in section: Top Story, [...]

  3. Actually, a similar deceit is being peddled about Iraq. The Obama campaign constantly claims that they ended the Iraq war and brought all the troops home. In fact, they tried desperately to keep thousands of troops there, and simply got kicked out – only then deciding to pick up this narrative of ending the occupation.houston wedding limo

  4. This really is an extremely amazing powerful resource that you're offering and you simply provide it away cost-free!! I that can match discovering websites of which be aware of the particular property value supplying you with an excellent learning resource for zero cost. We truly dearly loved examining these pages. Appreciate it!
    Ralph lauren pas cher

  5. Israel is a danger to America, we need to not let them scam our tax dollars

  6. That's how brave our soldiers are.. that is why i salute them for their hardwork and for their patience and for their courage to still fight until they get freedom. dermatologist AZ

  7. War and all the problems that occurred in Afghanistan is very bad. There are a lot of people who were there and we had to act immediately.

  8. Stopping the war is not easy. There are many people who are looking for lots of action and solutions to be able to find a way out of the causes of a war could happen.

  9. Maent i gyd wedi agweddau cyfateb a meddwl o ran rhedeg busnes ac rwy'n credu bod y ffactorau sy'n eu gwneud yn wahanol i'r rhai y mae eu busnes bob amser yn peri pryder. Rwyf wedi cynnwys amrywiaeth o awgrymiadau yn seiliedig ar fy arsylwadau ohonynt.
    Fishing California

  10. Sentitzen complacency arazo handi bat izan daiteke, batez ere, enpresak urte asko ezarritako que han sido. Industrien guztiak oso lehiakorra da, eta inoiz baino gehiago behar dugu clever lortzeko. Onena enpresa estrategia bat da, bezeroei zaharrak mantentzeko.
    Austin Car Accident Attorneys

  11. Li se remakab yo wè ki jan ki klè tout bagay lè ou deja konnen ki jan anpil tranzaksyon biznis ke ou vle vire yon pwofi. Trè kèk biznis pran tan nan kalkile sib la, men yon biznis siksè toujou fè.
    Bear Viewing Alaska

  12. Afghanistan is one of the many abandoned by many people because there are a lot of conflicts that are not completed because of a lot of things. This is one event that happens like.Sean Nevett

  13. Wars in Afghanistan had been going on long enough and it will only make people become more miserable. I think the war will only make the situation worse because the collapse of the country's economy.

  14. This website has very good content. Please let me know if you're looking for a article author for your weblog. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset.

  15. The best blog always in th? nh?a serves information regarding products ads

  16. I am writing a research paper and collecting information on this topic. Your post is one of the better that I have read. Thank you for putting this information into one location.

  17. You are every reason, every hope, and every dream I've ever had, and no matter what happens to us in the future, everyday we are together is the greatest day of my life. I will always be yours.

  18. you completed certain good points there. I did a search on the subject and found nearly all persons will agree with your blog

  19. Why we are not going o left out that place ..Please share more part to understand the things easily..I want to know more about this.

  20. Absolutely perfect to explain the things.It helps me a lot to understand the things.thanks for share the great info.

  21. Afghans Love Being Occupied..Generally I do not learn article on blogs, however I would like to say that this write-up very forced me to take a look at and do so! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, quite nice post.

  22. Providing professional and educational essay services for students and others who looking to go fr professional exams. It should help you in study.

  23. This is nice website concerns about antiwar issue which is quite well they work for peace in the world we need peace for ever thing thanks