The Economic Costs of ‘a Permanent War Economy’

John Glaser, November 08, 2012

Probably the most dominant rhetorical pitch thrown about by politicians and media pundits regarding defense cuts is that they will cost the country much-needed jobs. Actually, the number of jobs in the military industrial complex that would be lost as a result of the puny defense cuts proposed in the sequestration deal is very low compared to the dooms-day predictions.

Of course, the other piece of the story is that government spending on the military should not be a jobs program, first and foremost because there are other menacing problems with permanent war and “a permanent war economy.”

That’s the subject of a new paper from Thomas K. Duncan and Christopher J. Coyne, economists at George Mason University. Here is the abstract:

How does the permanent war economy interact, and subsume, the private, non-military economy? Can the two remain at a distance while sharing resource pools? This paper argues that they cannot. Once the U.S. embarked upon the path of permanent war, starting with World War II, the result was a permanent war economy. The permanent war economy continuously draws resources into the military sector at the expense of the private economy, even in times of peace. We explore the overlooked costs of this process. The permanent war economy does not just transfer resources from the private economy, but also distorts and undermines the market process which is ultimately responsible for improvements in standards of living.

The paper is introduced with a quote from Eisenhower’s farewell address where he coined the phrase military industrial complex. “In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military-industrial complex. The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist.”

Duncan and Coyne “try to show how the military-industrial complex has turned into what some in the Pentagon call a ‘self-licking ice cream cone’ more concerned with self-preservation than national security,” according to Time.

They explore how at this point rising military budgets has become self-perpetuating and based on things like jobs, as opposed to estimates on how much spending the US actually would need to defend itself.

“As the military-industrial complex lacks a mechanism for meaningful economic feedback and correction,” they write, “once the economic activity has been set in motion, there is no true method of correction. This leads to the second implication, which is that the permanent war economy is self-extending.”




37 Responses to “The Economic Costs of ‘a Permanent War Economy’”

  1. How many times will libertarians repeat the obvious before they realise no one is listening?
    I could have written this paper in the 8th grade. This isn't news. People just don't give a shit. They don't think in terms of numbers of facts and history. It's all moralizing and emotion and herd identity.

  2. [...] The Economic Costs of ‘a Permanent War Economy’ Nov 11 911 Cover-up, Pentagon John Glaser November 08, 2012 Antiwar.com [...]

  3. We repeat it because its true. What she we do? Just keep our mouths shut and avoid the truth? And yes, we're well aware that most simple minds are not listening. Most are sheep and will remain that way. You can't educate the stupid but you can reach a few whose IQ is higher than 40.

  4. Who will proceed to do nothing.
    Reform is pissing in the wind as long as human beings are human beings. Transhumanism, or fuck 'em – who cares if they die?

  5. thanks bloog good adminadasd

  6. thanks bloog good adminxzczxcxz

  7. thanks bloog good adminzczczx

  8. There really needs to be a reliable, consistent counter-news source who has the confidence and trust of US victim nations to get the straight scoop from their point of view.

  9. A very informative site. The way you have share this information is really very appreciative. Hope to see more on this topic here. Thanks for posting this information here.

  10. Advantageously, the article is really the best on this notable topic. I harmonize with your conclusions and will thirstily look forward to your approaching updates

  11. I tag it to my favorites internet site list and will be checking back soon. Please check out my web site also and let me know what you think.

  12. I absolutely enjoyed every single small little bit of it. I’ve you bookmarked your internet site to look at out the new stuff you post.

  13. I think the economic costs of ‘a Permanent War Economy’ will will have more than the other economies

  14. War is not soloution its a problem from which we have to get out. SEO Manchester best seo ranking service.

  15. i think war is not soloution of any thing so we should avoid war.

  16. Hmm look at America one of biggest economy of the world but having fought so many wars like in iraq,afghanistan,vietnam it is now leading towards bank default so i totally agree with the fact that war leads to economic destruction.

  17. Yeah @john i agree with you war is not solution so please don't fight and make your positive thinking.

  18. Xoftmade offers shared, business, dedicated web hosting solutions, web development and domain registration services in Pakistan. We offer lowest prices for hosting and website development.

  19. I would like to say thank for sharing this great article.

  20. Thank you very much for this great article..

  21. You were supposed to stop reading at this point (assuming that a) some of you can actually read and b) you read that far into this waste of time blog post): "There was no way of being certain if the strike was indeed American, or for that matter if it was a drone strike at all, although it had all the markings of one." thANKS

  22. A very informative site. The way you have share this information is really very appreciative.

  23. THANKS

  24. Thanks for sharing

  25. i think war is not soloution of any thing so we should avoid war.

    buy paper online for college

  26. Really your post is very good and I appreciate it.
    essay writing help online

  27. nice post.

  28. nice post.<a href = "http://www.helpwithcollegeessay.com/3-skills-every-student-should-have/">Write essays for money

  29. nice post.<a href = "http://www.helpwithcollegeessay.com/3-skills-every-student-should-have/">Write essays for money

  30. I am so impressed to read your content.
    buy essays for college

  31. I’ve you bookmarked your blog to look at out the new stuff you post.thank you for sharing
    a href="http://www.assignmentconsultants.com/the-foundation-of-a-good-essay/">college essay writing

  32. very nice blog i must say keep share blogs like these

  33. Your article is very good,memory is too beautiful,I am so happy to read this. Thank you for sharing with us!

  34. I like the means you and writing and accepted wisdom, expect read more from you, I determination remain approaching…
    <a href="http://www.optimizedbusinessresults.com/news/safety-expert-southwell-from-the-group-hbos-says-holidaymakers-need-to-remain-

    vigilant/">Robin Southwell

  35. I like the means you and writing and accepted wisdom, expect read more from you, I determination remain approaching…
    Robin Southwell

  36. I am delighted to find some more information. coursework help service

  37. I really enjoyed this feature module introduction. Thanks. essay help websites