Syria’s Rebellion Ain’t So Popular

John Glaser, December 03, 2012

The Syrian rebellion has never been a popular revolution, but now even some who advocated the demise of the Assad regime have begun to doubt the value of the brutal civil war and what it has done for Syria.

McClatchy has a brilliant report on “Ebrahem,” a Syrian revolutionary who “openly wonders whether he and his fellow revolutionaries have done the right thing.”

“What will we tell our children? That we started this revolution and destroyed the country?”

…The first demonstrations, particularly in Damascus, were hopeful ones and deliberate in their displays of unity among the country’s sects and ethnicities. But as the violence grew, it was the Sunni Muslim Arab population that armed itself. Though the narrative that has persisted is that arming the rebellion was the only choice, many peaceful demonstrators like Ebrahem are tepid in their support of that decision, and some oppose it outright.

…Ebrahem, who openly questions the existence of God, did not help start the rebellion in Hasaka to see it empower conservative Islamist militias, though that is exactly what it has done across the country.

And this is coming from a self-described “revolutionary.” Imagine what the rest of Syria – the majority of the population by most accounts – thinks of the Free Syrian Army and the alleged humanitarian imperative to arm them to victory.

Update: See also this Bloomberg report from September:

Although foreigners can be outraged that people would get upset over small inconveniences, given the suffering and atrocities caused by government forces, it is striking that a “silent majority” in Damascus and Aleppo is blaming the rebels and the uprising.

At first, “Aleppo witnessed an amazing number of civil disobedience and popular movements that included unions, lawyers, doctors, engineers and university students,” said Fadi Salem, a Syrian academic based in the gulf region who visited Aleppo recently. But that support fell away when violence came with the flow of armed rebels to the city.

“The population was not ready for this,” he said. “The armed rebels are mostly not from the city itself. They don’t have organic popular support.”




35 Responses to “Syria’s Rebellion Ain’t So Popular”

  1. No country in the world not Switzerland or Sweden could tolorate their police officers being killed at the Rate Syria was losing theirs .

  2. Yeah, I agree with you Eric. I am hoping that they make some changes that include this one.

  3. What? All police officers should be killed.

  4. Can they really be this naive? Don't they know what a Color revolution is? or that it was always intenended to wheel on the fundamentalist Jihadists to take over?

    This was printed in the London press over a year ago, spelling it out line by line.

  5. "The Syrian rebellion has never been a popular revolution." Says who? Russian TV? Anitwar.com is a joke on this topic…

  6. The whistle-blowers and moles of Washington.

    It has been leaked it was a Color Revolution, planned for years and lavishly funded. Of course if you don't object to Colonialism 2.0 taking over the Arab lands ……….

  7. The so-called Syrian revolution has nothing to do with democracy. It is part of a long-standing zionist plan to demolish all the arab states which might be a block to its hegemony in the region, and which oppose US interests. Whatever I think of Assad, I think much, much less of the muisguided "revolutionaries" who are speeding Syria on 9its way to destruction. You only have to look across the Med to Libya to see where it all will go.

  8. A Clean Break, A New Approach to Safeguard the Realm 1996 , prepared by the Neo-Cons for their mate "Benn" Netayahu.

  9. The people of Syria told the world from day one.., when over million people in Damascus and said..,
    God, Syria, Bashir Al Assad va ba..,it means nothibg but syria, god and Bashir Al Assad, thats what the message was and we echoed their vice, if U.S or EU neo fascism don't get this load and clear message then they are once again acting as if they were stupid won't listen to the voice of people, not that they done it before, but this time making sure if it.

  10. That we started this revolution and destroyed the country?”

  11. Why? Are you one of the jihadists? (Funny, my spell checker flagged that word and suggested 'sadists') The news from Syria makes it pretty clear, even as our obedient press tries to spin in favor of the rebels, that they are just as bad or worse than what they want to replace.

  12. H Clinton's exhortations to the NI rebels are the exact opposite of those to the loveable terrorists in Syria, though Syria had been a peaceful country for far longer than NI.

  13. Yeah, so I noticed. But Clinton sees Northern Ireland as one of her "successes".

  14. I’m not sure why but this weblog is loading extremely slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it a problem on my end? I’ll check back later and
    see if the problem still exists.

  15. The brutal civil war and what it has done for Syria.

  16. The Arab Spring is nothing but a bunch of Muslim nations twisting in wind because of poverty, caused by backwardness due to centuries of religious fundamentalism and overpopulation.

  17. ….while benevolent Western powers have tried their hardest to help these backwards, benighted countries. Your analysis is especially correct when applied to the cosmopolitan, religion-diverse, quasi-socialist Syria who population is 'over-populated' with refugees caused by the American destruction of Iraq in 2003.

    Please comment more – your grasp of the complex geo-political is uncommonly insightful!

  18. It ain't a civil war, the Arab Spring is not a bunch of Muslim nations twisting in the wind.

    It was planned in Washington with a fortune spent on it that makes an emperor's ransome pale asco-ordinated Color revolutios, as they areknown, to take control of the Middle East.

    However in Syria – it has been leaked in London – paramilitaries wouldbe required so the Mohajadeen Jihadists were reactivaed on Washington's behalf by the Saudis.

    For an insight go to the McClatchy article link in the articel and read the comments below it.

    o

  19. Everyone should read the diary of Moshe Sharet who was the second prime minister of Israel. It is clear the Israel planned to attack syria in 1953 but ben gurion elected to attack Egypt first because Egypt was scheduled to get modern military equipment from Russia. In 1955 Israel attack Gaza and Took the Suez canal but Ik told them to get out. Syria is the war long planned and it has nothing to do with rebels but invasion. The same murders who killed so many in Libya are in Syria.

  20. very blog good adminsadsasd

  21. very blog good adminssadsada

  22. very blog good adminsasdadas

  23. There really needs to be a reliable, consistent counter-news source who has the confidence and trust of US victim nations to get the straight scoop from their point of view.

  24. hat communities divert law enforcement resources from violent crimes to illegal drug offenses, the risk of punishment for engaging i

  25. sadorcement resources from violent crimes to illegal drug offenses, the risk of punishment for engaging i

  26. munities divert law enforcement resources from violent crimes to illegal drug offenses, the risk of punishment for engaging i

  27. t resources from violent crimes to illegal drug offenses, the risk of punishment for engaging i

  28. She is afraid that our future generation will read and learn about Prof. Yunus in textbook and history book more than her father once she is dead.

  29. I have been surfing online more than three hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It's pretty worth enough for me..

  30. You are every reason, every hope, and every dream I've ever had, and no matter what happens to us in the future, everyday we are together is the greatest day of my life. I will always be yours.

  31. Syria’s Rebellion Ain’t So Popular is the good to know about this article.I am very grateful to know this.

  32. This website has very good content. Please let me know if you're looking for a article author for your weblog. You have some really great posts and I feel I would be a good asset.

  33. Syria’s Rebellion Ain’t So Popular..why he is popular.please let me know, about the complete information..

  34. Không ph?i ai ? Hà N?i c?ng có th? bi?t h?t nh?ng ??a ?i?m thú v? và h?p d?n n?i b?n và c? gia ?ình có th? có nh?ng phút giây th? giãn. H?n n?a, không ph?i ??a ?i?m nào c?ng có m?c giá và ?i?u ki?n h?p lí ?úng theo ý mu?n c?a b?n. Sau ?ây là vài ??a ch? khu ngh? d??ng g?n hà n?i v?i ch?t l??ng và giá c? h?p d?n b?n có th? tham kh?o cho mùa hè s?p ??n.khu ngh? d??ng g?n hà n?i

    Ngoài ra, v?i h? th?ng ki?n trúc hi?n ??i, m?t b? su?i khoáng nóng c?c kì tinh khi?t và s?ch s? là ?i?m nh?n cho khu du l?ch ??c ?áo. V resort c?ng là m?t tòa ki?n trúc ??p, g?n g?i thiên nhiên. Bao g?m nh?ng ti?n nghi ??y ?? nh? spa, nhà sàn, hay phòng gym và t?t t?n t?t nh?ng ph??ng ti?n gi?i trí mà b?n có th? d? dàng tìm th?ykhu resort g?n hà n?i

  35. Chúng tôi l?a ch?n s? 1 cho làm sáng da trong n?m 2014 là Lux chuyên sâu. Làm sáng da tuy?t v?i này ???c th?c hi?n v?i các thành ph?n ch?t l??ng cao nh?t. Lux công trình chuyên sâu ?? thay ??i s? xu?t hi?n c?a da mà không ?nh h??ng ??n c?u trúc ho?c ch?c n?ng da
    kem d??ng da nào t?t nh?t

    .Nó ?i kèm v?i m?t ti?n 90 ngày tr? l?i ??m b?o và b?n có th? nh?n ???c m?t ngu?n cung c?p 30 ngày cho ít h?n $ 35 khi b?n mua gói giá tr?.
    kem d??ng da t?t nh?t

    H? hi?n c?ng ?ang cung c?p mi?n phí v?n chuy?n trên t?t c? các ??n ??t hàng trong n??c. Click vào ?ây ?? truy c?p vào các trang web chính th?c Lux chuyên sâu
    kem d??ng da nào t?t