The Empire Costs Too Much, In Cash and Conscience

John Glaser, July 12, 2013

Gulf Aircraft carrier

You won’t hear it put this way by anyone in Washington, but the main reason cuts to the defense budget are worrying officials is that they make it more difficult to police the world.

In Foreign Affairs, Michael O’Hanlon and Bruce Riedel suggest a cost-saving measure for America’s empire in the Middle East: opening more U.S. military bases in the region. Instead of relying as it has on expensive “aircraft carriers in and near the Persian Gulf,” the U.S. should move its military presence back onto land in at least three different Gulf states.

The primary purpose of having U.S. military bases peppered throughout the Middle East has traditionally been to exert control over geo-politically vital oil-rich countries and to allow for a rapid and coordinated use of military force at Washington’s command. As a Top Secret National Security Council briefing put it in 1954, “the Near East is of great strategic, political, and economic importance,” as it “contains the greatest petroleum resources in the world” as well as “essential locations for strategic military bases in any world conflict.”

O’Hanlon and Riedel don’t even consider the legitimacy of America’s military presence in the Middle East; for them, it is a natural law that can’t be questioned. So when faced with strained budgets that can’t support a sprawling, costly, and unwarranted empire, they try to figure minor cost cutting measures around the edges instead of reevaluating our military postures as a whole.

A CSIS report last year took a different tack, arguing that “disappearing finances; rising alternative power centers; declining US military predominance; lack of efficacy of key non-military instruments of power; and reduced domestic patience for global adventures,” all require a rethinking of U.S. grand strategy with an eye towards roll-back.

The very definition of grand strategy is holding ends and means in balance to promote the security and interests of the state. Yet, the post-war US approach to strategy is rapidly becoming insolvent and unsustainable – not only because Washington can no longer afford it but also, crucially, because it presumes an American relationship with friends, allies, and rivals that is the hallmark of a bygone era. If Washington continues to cling to its existing role on the premise that the international order depends upon it, the result will be increasing resistance, economic ruin, and strategic failure.

That first sentence there is one of the most honest you’ll ever see from an elite DC foreign policy think tank. U.S. foreign policy is ultimately promoting “the security and interests of the state.” It isn’t for your sake. It benefits the government and the private interests aligned with it.

What O’Hanlon and Riedel also don’t mention, except for a passing reference to “complex” “internal political factors” in Saudi Arabia and the 1998 Khobar Towers bombing, is that the problem with the U.S. military presence in the Middle East isn’t just its financial cost; it also generates widespread hatred and resentment of the U.S. government and was the underpinning of al-Qaeda’s propaganda aimed at motivating Muslims to attack America and Americans abroad. Huge majorities of people in the Arab world strongly object to the permanent U.S. military presence in their lands.

The nefarious nature of the U.S. presence was articulated fittingly enough by O’Hanlon and Riedel, however. The various U.S. aircraft carriers in the Gulf, each with about 72 fighter jets on board, are “to provide the airpower that [the U.S.] would need during a possible conflict with Iran.” We used to hear this rhetoric about Iraq back in the day. Experience should show it’s less a “just in case” kind of thing, and more a dependable military force to implement the expected U.S. war on Iran.

And finally, O’Hanlon and Riedel address the potential problems of building more land bases in the Middle East in the context of the rising political awareness and activism in the Middle East. It could be hilarious satire if they weren’t so sincere:

Some will argue that more planes on the ground in the Qatar and the United Arab Emirates would tie the United States even more closely to those countries’ royal families, at a time when the Arab Spring challenges their ability to hold onto power. The United States could also be implicated in any regime crackdowns against citizens. That is part of why the United States should diversify its combat airpower presence to at least two, if not three, places. But it is worth remembering that, in fact, the United States has already thrown its support behind those governments, and the Saudi royals, for years. In other words, the United States is already seen as being very close to them. Getting even closer will not change perceptions that much. It is, therefore, a tolerable additional risk.

The “risk” that more people get angry with the U.S. for propping up the brutal tyrannies in the Persian Gulf is “tolerable” because, heck, we’re already hated for that very reason! Might as well pile on! Notice that they don’t mention the moral questions of upholding mass political repression for millions of people across the region. They only care about perceptions it might cause, not the act of doing it.




44 Responses to “The Empire Costs Too Much, In Cash and Conscience”

  1. Aircraft carriers are growing ever more vulnerable to sophisticated anti ship missiles. The dollar probably would crash if one or more of these behemouths was sunk in a war with Iran.

  2. Part of the Jimmy Carter doctrine was the development of a rapid deployment force that was to defend our "interests" in the Middle East by keeping Russia and China out. Yeah, morals are never an issue with our government since they feel morals are only for idealists, profit is the name of the game.

  3. And finally, O’Hanlon and Riedel address the potential problems of building more land bases in the Middle East in the context of the rising political awareness and activism in the Middle East. It could be hilarious satire if they weren’t so sincere:

  4. [...] the Anti-War blog, John Glaser looks at the ongoing costs of [...]

  5. "Our interests' in the middle east. You mean English and European and Israel interests. They get all the oil along with the communist Chinese. England's penetration and control of Washington , especially the pentagon, and the press including the indy media is truly amazing. Russia just announced 650 billion barrels of oil. Venezeula has 1.5 trillion. Brazil over 100 billion new barrels. The Bakken on Land in the USA around 25 billion barrels. The deep gulf perhaps 25 billion more. Who needs the middle east, only the English empire , which controls much of europe still, not the usa. I think of the USA military as redcoats now, or another branch of the IDF. Heck who put those corrupt Sauds in Power by 'our' best friends the English, the same country that created the crazed war state of Israel. Hand the problems back to England and roll on back to the Americas where there are plenty of resources for the next 200 years. No more wars for England's empire or their Kin in the USA.

  6. And finally, O’Hanlon and Riedel address the potential problems of building more land bases in the Middle East in the context of the rising political awareness and activism in the Middle East. It could be hilarious satire if they weren’t so sincere:

  7. Excellent beat ! I would like to apprentice even as you amend your website, how can i subscribe for a weblog web site?
    The account aided me a appropriate deal. I were a little bit familiar
    of this your broadcast offered brilliant clear concept

  8. Hey there! Do you use Twitter? I’d like to follow you if that would be okay. I’m
    absolutely enjoying your blog and look forward to new updates.

  9. US biggest import = resentment. Biggest export = violence.

  10. Unquestionably believe that that you stated.
    Your favorite justification seemed to be at the
    web the easiest factor to be aware of. I say to you, I definitely get irked whilst
    people consider concerns that they plainly do not know about.
    You managed to hit the nail upon the highest and outlined out the entire thing with no need side effect , people can
    take a signal. Will likely be again to get more.
    Thanks

  11. Very nice blog and articles. I am realy very happy to visit your blog. Now I am found which I actually want. I check your blog everyday and try to learn something from your blog. Thank you and waiting for your new post. is bubblegum casting legitimate

  12. New version nike heels products is lightweight, stylish, and very comfortable.The air jordans heels keep you Thanks. the top tens

  13. Well That's things i was trying to find. I like your site and that i appericiate your time and efforts. Your article is extremely useful for me personally thanks. is bubblegum casting legitimate

  14. Too much reading of the foreign policy press of the ruling elite by Glaser.
    Is he in love

  15. I am realy very happy to visit your blog. Now I am found which I actually want. I check your blog

  16. Well I seemed to be in fact experiencing the particular great helpful suggestions from the weblog as well as I placed respect towards copy writer on this publish.
    Top Ten Places to visit

  17. Well That's things i was trying to find. I like your site and that i appericiate your time and efforts. Your article is extremely useful for me personally and many more to sort out .Download fruit ninja for pc

  18. It's All About Pictures Quotes Pictures, Sayings Pictures, Artistic Pictures, Mix Wallpapers, Different Information, And Many More .
    Daily quotes and sayings collection

  19. nive blog very informative !Thaks For the posting !
    Top Ten Smartphones in the World

  20. Too much reading of the foreign policy press of the ruling elite by Glaser.
    Is he in love? Does he have ambitions? Why soil oneself by wallowing in this crap?
    To find out what of importance will transpire historically, look down not up, young John.

  21. It's All About Pictures Quotes Pictures, Sayings Pictures, Artistic Pictures, Mix Wallpapers, Different Information, And Many More …
    Quotes And Sayings Collection

  22. It's All About Pictures Quotes Pictures, Sayings Pictures, Artistic Pictures, Mix Wallpapers, Different Information

  23. Well That's things i was trying to find. I like your site and that i appericiate your time and efforts. Your article is extremely useful for me personally

  24. Too much reading of the foreign policy press of the ruling elite by Glaser.
    Is he in love? Does he have ambitions? Why soil oneself by wallowing in this crap?
    To find out what of importance will transpire historically, look down not up, young John. Highpr Blog Comment

  25. Well That's things i was trying to find. I like your site and that i appericiate your time and efforts. Your article is extremely useful for me personally and many more to sort out.

  26. I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! Free Bet

  27. Well site has lots of advantage. I found many interesting things from this site. I like it very much. Its so interesting.I want to sharing this topic with some of my close friends. Greg Aziz

  28. Well I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site coco palms condo

  29. Well That's things i was trying to find. I like your site and that i appericiate your time and efforts. Your article is extremely useful for me personally and many more to sort out. altis life server mieten

  30. Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Fanbox Auto Like Script

  31. My niece and nephew told me about these, and they're delicious! I hate taking vitamins because of nasty aftertaste, but not with these, now I can't wait to take my yummy tummies! Have used this product for many years and found it well worth the expense. I definitely have noticed a difference after taking this for a couple of weeks. I was using the Finish Quantum Powerball tablets, but their smell of bleach made me not want to buy them any more. hello Method I love you! http://tinyurl.com/mwpv758 Though the minute she stopped taking it, it all came back. I also think it is helping with my forearm tendinitis. The coating is a nice color and appears to be strong enough to resist an accidental drop… I went back to the Lansinoh disposable nursing pads, which I love! I really like using this thing but for me…ahem…I need something with more diameter. SUCCESS! Cold & creamy is definitely the way to go here. The shipment process was what i expected, I knew this would be a good product to purchase and was excited when i received it. http://www.ebay.com/

  32. OPEN MULTIPLE URL'S WITH JUST ONE CLICK
    BEST SEO TOOL NOW YOU DO NOT HAVE TO WORRIED ABOUT OPENING VARIOUS

    URL'S WITH THE SINGLE CLICK OF YOUR MOUSE BUTTON. THE

    FAST URL OPENER CAN HELP YOU ACHIEVE THIS GOAL AND

    SAVE YOU SOMETIME AND BOTHERATION OF CLICKING THE

    MOUSE KEYS AGAIN AND AGAIN.
    ENJOY THE WONDERS OF FAST URL OPENER AND SAVE TIME

  33. Jimmy Carter doctrine was the development of a rapid deployment force that was to defend our "interests" in the Middle East by keeping Russia and China out. Yeah, morals are never an issue with our government
    Fort Myers real estate lawyer

  34. This is a good movie. My camera is the digital Elph S500. I would recommend it to anyone of any age – even adults kick-starting their math career again – it provides a wonderful place to build from. L-arginine Supplement For Sale http://www.allewaa.org/542/arginine-metabolic-dis… The clear plastic piece keeps them locked in place and is completely unnoticeable. However, what you cannot tell from the picture is that you have to hold the top cover while pouring or the entire solid white portion of the pitcher (including the filter) will tilt and fall out of place, which can lead to spilled water. Sometimes she has to make a copy of something and instead of getting in her car and going to Staples to pay a nickel a copy, she can now put it on the scanner glass and push the "copy" button. its a good product but u need a pretty fast computer for it to play big movie files http://www.ask.com/

  35. I like your site and that i appericiate your time and efforts. Your article is extremely useful for me personally and many more to sort out. altis life server mieten

  36. It's all about sharing the education

  37. it is a natural law that can’t be questioned. So when faced with strained budgets that can’t support a sprawling, costly, and unwarranted empire, they try to figure minor cost cutting measures around the edges instead of reevaluating our military postures as a whole.Oks instant racing machines

  38. If Washington continues to cling to its existing role on the premise that the international order depends upon it, the result will be increasing resistance, economic ruin, and strategic failure.firstcnaclasses.com – First CNA classes

  39. So when faced with strained budgets that can’t support a sprawling, costly, and unwarranted empire, they try to figure minor cost cutting measures around the edges instead of reevaluating our military postures as a whole.find schools for phlebotomists

  40. Tenderloin AIDS Resource Center, the Santa Clara Department of Public Health AIDS Program, and the San Diego AIDS Foundation. She is currently the Community Organizing Director for the Transgender, Gender Variant & Intersex Justice Project. For her lifetime of activism, she recently received the Social Justice Sabbatical Award from the Vanguard Public Foundation.Stephen Guzman

  41. military bases in the region. Instead of relying as it has on expensive “aircraft carriers in and near the Persian Gulf,” the U.S. should move its military presence back onto land in at least three different Gulf states.Samsung fridge not cooling

  42. I like your site and that i appericiate your time and efforts. Your article is extremely useful for me

  43. More than 35% of respondents said they haven’t started developing compliance plans, and the remainder of respondents were somewhere in the middle.Natural Disasters

  44. So when faced with strained budgets that can’t support a sprawling, costly, and unwarranted empire, they try to figure minor cost cutting measures around the edges instead of reevaluating our military postures as a whole.Brad Reifler's farm for sale