November 12, 2003

IRAQ: IT'S GETTING UGLY
U.S. threatens 'harsh measures,' while Iraqi insurrection spreads
by Justin Raimondo

George W. Bush had barely finished bemoaning the "democracy deficit" in his speech to the National Endowment for Democracy when General John Abizaid, commander of U.S. troops in the Middle East, showed the true face of the American occupation. The headline said it all: "Top U.S. general warns of harsh measures unless attacks stop."

Apparently such measures as kicking down doors, conducting impromptu house-to-house searches, terrifying Iraqi children, shooting a pro-American member of the Baghdad Governing Council – and killing 6,000 other Iraqis – aren't considered harsh enough. "We have the capabilities and equipment," the Mayor of Fallujah reported the General as saying.

One wonders what Abizaid the Merciless has in mind.

It's funny, but we often hear the War Party bloviating about how the current conflict is like World War II – yeah, but which side are we? It is positively eerie that a real life American general sounds like nothing so much as a German officer in some World War II movie set in occupied France:

"Zere vill be reprisals!"

This is what it's like to become an imperial power: ambitious generals are … imperious. Hearts and minds need to be won, but they are in Washington, not Iraq: "We have the capabilities and equipment." Translation: We'll kill as many as we have to.

We are told that U.S. forces must remain in Iraq until "stability" is achieved, but then we turn around and commit a series of provocative and profoundly destabilizing acts, of which Abizaid's ultimatum is only the most recent. At times, the American occupation of Iraq takes on the aura of a ritual humiliation. The American General's command to jump through this hoop and bark is being met with defiance. The Associated Press quotes one Najih Latif Abbas as saying:

''Neither America, nor the father of America, scares us. Iraqi men are striking at Americans and they retaliate by terrifying our children.''

Fakhri Fayadh, a 60-year-old farmer, was willing to go on the record with a prediction: American reprisals, he said,

''Will only increase our spite and hatred of them. If they think that they will scare us, they are wrong. Day after day, Americans will be harmed and attacks against them will increase.''

Half of Americans now say that the Iraq war was not worth fighting – up from 43 percent in October. And we are only just now entering the first phase of a long guerrilla war, what I called "the real war" some months ago. If I may be permitted an "I told you so" moment, here's some soothsaying from the lips of Raimondodamus, written before the fall of Baghdad:

"In our accelerated, totally-wired, up-to-the-minute, fully-'embedded' hyper-reality, where immediacy is everything, the war will have lasted but a few weeks, a month or so at the most. But the real war is going to be the long occupation, during which US troops will be sitting ducks for every Islamist nutball in a region filled with them – and the War Party will be looking for new lands to conquer. The danger could not be greater.

"God help us all."

First of all, God help the troops. The news is filled with stories of their discontent, of ill treatment of the wounded, of a woman soldier who is being forced to choose between going AWOL and keeping her children, and growing cynicism and doubts in the ranks about their mission. If half of us don't think the war was worth it, then that statistic is no doubt roughly replicated in the military.

We have the equipment and the capability, but Niall Ferguson is right: Americans have no stomach for empire-building. Which is why George W. Bush had better devise an exit strategy, and fast, or he'll be exiting the White House.

The latest mishap, the killing of the American-appointed leader of Sadr City and his driver by U.S. soldiers, symbolizes the tragic idiocy of our involvement in Iraq. Apparently the council leader, Muhammed Kaabi, approached the gates of the council chambers and objected to the searching of his car by American guards. A fight ensued, the soldiers shot Kaabi – and, after wrestling the still struggling driver to the floor, shot and killed him, too..

Sadr City is an impoverished Shi'ite ghetto, the Iraqi version of, say, South Central Los Angeles, and a prime breeding ground for Islamic terrorists. The irony is that Sadr City, which writhed under the Ba'athist lash as long as Saddam was in power, ought to be a bastion of support for the "liberation." Yet thousands marched through the streets demanding the U.S. get out. These are not Ba'athist diehards, but some of Saddam's greatest victims, members of the majority Muslim sect that the U.S. cannot afford to alienate. So far, the Shia militias outside the "Sunni Triangle" have refrained from joining the insurgency, and their leaders, dominant in the southern part of the country, have counseled restraint. An incident of this kind could easily push them over the edge and, for the first time, give the Iraqi insurrection a truly national dimension.

NOTES IN THE MARGIN

I apologize for the short column, but I'm way behind on my talk for the upcoming meeting of the John Randolph Club. It's lucky I had a great visit with Scott Richert, the executive editor of Chronicles magazine, who came to the Bay Area recently. I had only bothered to look at one side of the schedule they sent me, as Scott pointed out: I turned it over and discovered I'm also to give a talk on civil liberties in wartime. By the time I get to New Orleans, I'll be too tired to indulge the pleasures of night life in the French Quarter. But then again, maybe not….

– Justin Raimondo

comments on this article?

 Please Support Antiwar.com

Antiwar.com
1200 Hamilton Ave.
Palo Alto, CA 94301

or Contribute Via our Secure Server
Credit Card Donation Form

Your contributions are now tax-deductible

Antiwar.com Home Page

Most recent column by Justin Raimondo

Archived columns

Iraq: It's Getting Ugly
11/12/03

George W. Bush, Trotskyite
11/10/03

Classic Raimondo:
Ein Volk, Ein Fuehrer, Ein Israel...
11/7/03

The Last Senator
11/5/03

The Deadliest Day
11/3/03

Iraq and Vietnam
10/31/03

Chickenhawk Sees Combat
10/29/03

Our 'Friends,' the Israelis
10/27/03

Rummy's Ruminations
10/24/03

Support Our Troops
10/22/03

Exit Stage Iraq?
10/20/03

Googling the War Party
10/17/03

A Day in the Life of the Empire
10/15/03

Fake 'Good News' from Iraq
10/13/03

US War Propaganda Is Pathetic
10/10/03

Hands Off Bob Novak!
10/8/03

Israel Is the Problem
10/6/03

L'Affaire Plame
10/3/03

The Neo-Jacobins
10/1/03

The Costs of War
9/29/03

War Party Whines Over Iraq Coverage
9/26/03

Instead of a Column
9/24/03

Another 9/11?
9/22/03

Are You Syria-ous?
9/19/03

Donald Rumsfeld, Peacenik?
9/17/03

Countdown to Catastrophe in the Middle East
9/15/03

Iraq Is the Flytrap
9/12/03

9/11 Conspiracy Chic
9/10/03

Bush Speech: No U-Turn on the Road to Empire
9/8/03

Imperial Eye for the Republican Guy
9/5/03

Iraq's Mystery Terrorists
9/3/03

The Dean Deception
8/27/03

The War Party Unmasked
8/25/03

America in Iraq: A Glutton for Punishment
8/22/03

Baghdad Bomb Blasted American Hubris
8/20/03

The Neocons Come Out
8/18/03

The Real Terror Masters
8/15/03

Iraq War Critics Purged
8/13/03

A Politically Correct War?
8/11/03

US Troops in Iraq Are Sitting Ducks
8/8/03

Dean vs. Loserman
8/6/03

Anthrax Anniversary
8/4/03

What Does Bush Have to Hide?
8/1/03

Mr. Sharon, Tear Down That Wall!
7/30/03

Who Lied Us Into War?
7/28/03

Bremer's Baghdad Bolsheviks
7/25/03

The Perversion of History
7/23/03

Coalition of Deceit
7/21/03

Military Morale Hits Bottom in Iraq
7/18/03

Saddam Meets the Man From U.N.C.L.E.
7/16/03

Bogus from the Beginning
7/14/03

'If It Feels Good Do It'
7/11/03

Mosaic of Lies
7/9/03

To Heck with Liberia!
7/7/03

Mourning in America
7/4/03

No Exit?
7/2/03

The Road Map
6/30/03

The Culture of Imperialism
6/27/03

The WMD Cult
6/25/03

The New Thought Police
6/23/03

Empire of Liberty?
6/20/03

The Gaza Trap
6/18/03

What's It All About?
6/16/03

Trotsky, Strauss, and the Neocons
6/13/03

Classic Raimondo:
Israel's Taliban
6/11/03

Behind the Lies
6/9/03

Liars 'R Us
6/6/03

Hell to Pay
6/4/03

Wackos, Weirdos and Wing-Dings
6/2/03

We Were Right
5/30/03

On to Tehran?
5/28/03

Classic Raimondo:
Decline and Fall
5/26/03

Outing the Neocons
5/23/03

Revolt Against the Neocons
5/21/03

Regime Change Roulette
5/19/03

Blowback in Riyadh
5/16/03

The Anti-Americans
5/14/03

Classic Raimondo: Living in a Soviet America
5/12/03

Smoking Gun
5/9/03

Mad Dogs of War
5/7/03

Whose 'Road Map'?
5/5/03

The Final Secret of 9/11
5/2/03

Neocons in Denial
4/30/03

Santorum's Sins
4/28/03

The Real Crisis
4/25/03

Screw the UN
4/23/03

Putting America First
4/21/03

Fickle 'Victory'
4/18/03

Nesting Habits of Washington's War Birds
4/16/03

Phase Two Begins
4/14/03

King George Returns
4/9/03

The Real War
4/7/03

World War IV
4/4/03

If This Be Treason
4/2/03

On the Middle East Escalator
3/31/03

A Perle of High Price
3/28/03

Iraqi Pandora
3/26/03

A No-Winner
3/24/03

Commissar Frum
3/22/03

Bluff and Bluster
3/21/03

Shine, Perishing Republic
3/19/03

This Isn't About You
3/17/03

What's It All About, Ari?
3/14/03

Postwar Blues
3/12/03

Reckless Warmongers
3/10/03

This War Is Treason
3/7/03

The Hapless Hegemon
3/5/03

Libertarianism in the Age of Empire
3/3/03

Notes from the Margin
2/28/03

Is War Inevitable?
2/26/03

War Party Stumbles
2/24/03

Vive la France!
2/21/03

A 'Toxic' Meme
2/19/03

Rallying for War
2/17/03

Rally Against Fear
2/14/03

One Battlefield, Two Wars
2/12/03

Antiwar Breakthrough!
2/10/03

The Lying Game
2/7/03

Free Taki!
2/5/03

The Kook Factor
2/3/03

Our Reds, and Theirs
1/31/03

Beware the Ides of March
1/29/03

Growing Up
1/27/03

Israel's Amen Corner
1/24/03

Target: Scott Ritter
1/22/03

Listen Up, Soldier
1/20/03

Watch Your Back
1/17/03

Going Crazy
1/15/03

Turning Point
1/13/03

War Party in Retreat
1/10/03

Hail Caesar?
1/8/03

Korean Ghosts
1/6/03

Do Neocons Exist?
1/3/03

Happy New Year?
1/1/03

Previous columns

Justin Raimondo is the editorial director of Antiwar.com. He is also the author of Reclaiming the American Right: The Lost Legacy of the Conservative Movement (with an Introduction by Patrick J. Buchanan), (1993), and Into the Bosnian Quagmire: The Case Against U.S. Intervention in the Balkans (1996). He is an Adjunct Scholar with the Ludwig von Mises Institute, in Auburn, Alabama, a Senior Fellow at the Center for Libertarian Studies, and writes frequently for Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture. He is the author of An Enemy of the State: The Life of Murray N. Rothbard.

Back to Antiwar.com Home Page | Contact Us