Turkey's rejection of the American military last week
was both courageous and unexpected. The parliament's
decision shocked arrogant Washington policymakers, who'd
expected capitulation. Dependable Turkey, they thought,
while a tough negotiator, always concedes in the
end.
Before the fateful vote, the U.S. had presumptuously
jumped ahead with planning the "Turkish front" for its
war on Iraq. Washington assumed - incorrectly - that
Turkey's only concern was money. Ankara's initial
request for $92 billion war compensation was summarily
refused. Washington offered $26 billion, smugly thinking
the cash-strapped Turks would concede.
However, the U.S. thought wrong. At a time when
pro-war Americans are eager to ascribe unflattering
motives to allies that oppose President Bush's push for
war, it's important to note that Turkey's defiance of
the most powerful nation on Earth owed as much to
principles as it did to cash.
The country's population is strongly anti-war. Since
1999, the Kurdish insurrection that left 30,000 dead has
ended. The government has reconstructed myriad destroyed
homes, while granting greater language rights for the
Kurds - who fear Iraqi Kurd provocations could ruin
everything for them by forcing a Turkish Army
crackdown.
Muslim yet secular, Turkey has always appealed to
Washington. Its borders with the Soviet Union made it a
strategic Cold War ally. Time and again, America has
interceded on Turkey's behalf. It prevented British
intervention after Turkey's 1974 invasion of Cyprus, and
has consistently supported the military - even in quite
undemocratic coups d'etat.
However, Turkey's decision exposed latent tensions.
Turks are able to compromise - but not about their
sovereignty.
On the Iraqi border, the army protects every mountain
pass against outside attack. In October, at a motel in
the dusty border town of Sirnak, I found a Turkish
intelligence officer awaiting me. "What're you doing
here?" he queried politely. "Don't you know about the
war?" He couldn't believe I was merely a wandering
journalist. Despite the Turkish- American friendship,
suspicions abound.
These were heightened once the American desire to
lead the Iraqi sweep became known. The Turkish army's
noncommittal stance on a U.S. attack before the vote
seemed like tacit opposition.
Hosting U.S. soldiers, the army fears, could
interfere with its operations. They could remain after
the war - perhaps for years. And that could curtail
Turkish counterterrorist incursions into Iraq. Since
they must placate Iraqi Kurds to gain trust, the
Americans, if present in Turkey, could hamper the
military.
Then there is the oil-rich northern Iraqi city,
Kirkuk. By controlling it, the Kurds could finance - and
arm - their own state. Iraqi Kurd independence, Turkey
fears, could incite a domestic revolt. A hypothetical
American sweep from Turkey would capture Kirkuk, foiling
both parties. This American plan contributed to
parliament's misgivings.
Additionally, Turkey has economic fears. Since 1992,
it's suffered at least $65 billion in lost,
never-reimbursed Iraqi trade. Saddled with unpayable
loans and hit by major recessions, Turkey became the
IMF's biggest-ever debtor. Yet no one remembers Turkey's
sacrifices for America. By declining today's bribery,
Turkey is taking a major economic risk.
America's offer ($26 billion) looks good only on
paper. The money (mostly loan guarantees) would be
controlled by international lenders and the U.S.
government. Far from a blank check, Turkey would win
only more debt.
Turkey's courageous stand against U.S. imperialism
represented democracy at its finest: pressured
parliamentarians voting for their constituents' true
wishes. Eastern Europe's groveling leaders, however,
have ignored widespread domestic anti-war sentiment.
Only the Turks have exhibited democracy.
Turkey's European Union candidacy bid has received
vocal American support. Against European stonewalling,
America has emphasized Turkey's secular, democratic
values. But since Turkey asserted its democratic will,
Washington has been furious. It's now threatening to
withdraw EU accession support.
Ironically, however, retraction of American support
could help Turkey. Chronically anti-Turkish Germany and
France, buoyed by Turkey's resolve, are confidently
opposing America. Perhaps Turkey's brave decision will
pay off, should Europe warm up to it. For, as it proved
by standing up to the greatest power in the world,
Turkey is leagues ahead of its Eastern European rivals
when it comes to
democracy.