Last month the US issued an ultimatum to Iran, demanding it fully cooperate with the IAEA by March or else face further action and possible measures at the UN Security Council. Micah Zenko, fellow at the Council on Foreign Relations, speculates that this “could indicate that the Obama administration is moving toward the zone of immunity logic.”
Zenko is referring to the Israeli standard for deciding to go to war with Iran. Up to now, the Israeli standard to attack Iran is not when it has nuclear weapons or presents an imminent threat to Israel, but rather when Iran’s nuclear program is sufficiently advanced and redundant across the country – although not being weaponized – that Israeli military action would be inadequate to significantly retard it.
The US standard, at least as commonly understood, has been a little stricter. Washington has implied it will resort to war only if Iran is demonstrably weaponizing its nuclear program and on the verge of having a nuclear bomb.
Despite the semantic differences, the two postures are essentially the same. Both the US and Israel have ignored the legal standard for resorting to war – to block an imminent attack, i.e. self-defense – and crafted their own standard, which says they can bomb Iran to smithereens if they judge that at some point in the future Iran might be able to deter US or Israeli aggression. Iran must be kept weak and defenseless, the thinking goes, otherwise we wouldn’t be able to obliterate them at will.
This speaks to Iran’s nuclear posture, which is aimed at what is sometimes called “a breakout capability.” In an environment of constant threats of war, economic sanctions, and being surrounded by the US military, Iran has tried to abstain from developing nuclear weapons while having the know-how needed to get there; this essentially is an attempt to have a deterrent without actually having a deterrent. They don’t get in trouble for having a weapon, but they are able to ward off attack or invasion.
US intelligence corroborates this analysis. As James Clapper, Director of National Intelligence, has repeatedly said, “We don’t believe they’ve actually made the decision to go ahead with a nuclear weapon.”
So if the US’s announcement of a March deadline really does indicate a gradual shift toward the more trigger-happy Israeli standard for preemption, “how would this new intelligence be presented as a justification for war?” Zenko asks. After all, “it is tough to make the case for going to war with Iran because it refused to concentrate its nuclear sites (that are under IAEA safeguards) in above-ground facilities that can be easily bombed.”
Setting a March deadline provides some certainty and perhaps coercive leverage to compel Iran to cooperate with the IAEA. But declaring deadlines also places U.S. “credibility” on the line, generating momentum to use force even if there is no new actionable intelligence that Iran has decided to pursue a nuclear weapon. Based on what we know right now, that would be a strategic miscalculation.
A strategic miscalculation…and a savage war crime. Bombing Iran without the justification of self-defense against an imminent attack would be a war crime, a war of aggression. In the words of the Nuremberg Tribunal, “To initiate a war of aggression is not only an international crime; it is the supreme international crime, differing only from other war crimes in that it contains within itself the accumulated evil of the whole.”
And the effects of such a war of choice would certainly be evil. As a recent report by former government officials, national security experts and retired military officers concluded “achieving more than a temporary setback in Iran’s nuclear program would require a military operation – including a land occupation – more taxing than the Iraq and Afghanistan wars combined.” More taxing, not just in dollar amounts and military resources, but in lives lost.
A recent study from the University of Utah’s Hinckley Institute of Politics found, an attack that tried to take out more than four of Iran’s main enrichment facilities would cause immediate casualties of an estimated “10,000 people.” And according to a 2009 study by the Center for Strategic and International Studies “any strike on the Bushehr nuclear reactor will cause the immediate death of thousands of people living in or adjacent to the site, and thousands of subsequent cancer deaths or even up to hundreds of thousands depending on the population density along the contamination plume.” The fierce insurgency and counter-insurgency efforts that would inevitably take place, including a flood of jihadist fighters from around the world à la Iraq, would mean hundreds of thousands of lives lost.
More than that, an attack on Iran would motivate them to actually start building nuclear weapons in order to deter further aggression, bringing exactly the result the war-mongers claim they’re trying to prevent.
So why would the Obama administration ratchet up the stakes and impose an arbitrary March deadline? They claim there is a diplomatic window. As Clinton explained, “What was meant about the March reference was either about the IAEA and its continuing work or the fact that we finished our election and now would be a good time to test the proposition that there can be some good-faith serious negotiations before the Iranians get into their elections.” Elections make diplomacy harder, so yes, there is a diplomatic window. But the Obama administration may have locked themselves into a box by implicitly adopting the Israeli standard for preemptive war on Iran.
saddivert law enforcement resources from violent crimes to illegal drug offenses, the risk of punishment for engaging i
you get drunk in Riyadh. You don't get a great job at an influence mill with that on your résumé. You do if Ambassador to Saudi Arabia means what doing the "important work" needed under current polic
get a great job at an influence mill with that on your résumé. You do if Ambassador to Saudi Arabia means what doing the "important work" needed under current polic
"So why would the Obama administration ratchet up the stakes and impose an arbitrary March deadline?"
Full Body Workout Routine
a war on iran would unleash hell for the US and americans world wide. I for one would not board a plane or go to crowded places again
nyc family photographers
The terrorists in the US will go insolvent. So, they won´t be able to terrorize the globe any more. However, extra-judicial murders by drones will proceed. They are right: U. s. Fool IS The Excellent The devil.
Removalists in Brisbane
There is nothing too messy or mistake too big for God. Reminds me of the hymn grace grace God's grace grace that is greater than all my sin.
There is nothing too messy or mistake too big for God. Reminds me of the hymn grace grace God's grace grace that is greater than all my sin.
I have never seen Obama as a lapdog for Israel. He made some serious mistakes in his first term (the Afghan troop surge and the illegal bombing of Libya and murder of Khaddafi come to mind) the main reasons of drooping eyelids
This is the game of high authorities and i would say what ever they will do its ok. http://www.amazines.com/article_detail_new.cfm/58… do visit it
thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking for.Hope that you will continue with Nice to very useful info
Setting a March deadline provides some certainty and perhaps coercive leverage to compel Iran to cooperate with the IAEA. But declaring deadlines also places U.S. “credibility” on the line, generating momentum to use force even if there is no new actionable intelligence that Iran has decided to pursue a nuclear weapon.
I am really enjoying reading your well written articles.
your résumé. You do if Ambassador to Saudi Arabia means what doing the "important work" needed under current policies
Nice discussion show here really great shared.
i like this post so much, thank you for shearing 823
Omega3 –
Only $9.97, Free Shipping*
Let us help our country, to be one of a good influence. And because of that, we can achieve a peace of mind and to have a peaceful heart.
Stop war! let peace come in our mind.
Nice article! thank you for sharing.
Let's make peace on our country. Be one of a good influence not an evil to make war.
The costs for recovered muscle cars are valued on the memories it gives an ordinary American.
Almost everyone likes to go on fishing trips, whether you do it just for fun, or for sport is entirely up to you.
Your pug needs a stimulating environment if it is going to live a long and healthy life.
Sometimes you just don’t have the time to do the workouts you would like.
You will certainly wish to acquire a quote from as many insurance policy companies as possible, just before making your decision.
There are always a number of tournaments in the United States, which is the house of the bass among other parts of the world.
If you are thinking about getting a pug dog, this article can help you make up your mind.
The sophisticated, small footprint of the 510 E Elliptical is perfect for any space.
Fish Oil Pills balanced formula are clinically proven to support your heart, joint, skin and cognitive health!
100% 60 DAY GUARANTEE – Just one pill used daily can produce a younger, smoother, more wrinkle free skin. TRY IT TODAY, nothing to lose. Most people notice a softening of the skin as a first result.
There was when a time when it was considered a condition sign, a statement, and a means of life.
Bass are no longer dealt with as a meals fish by the bulk of fishermen. When they capture basses, they released it as soon as it is captured.
Omega 3
The type is believed to have initially came to be in around 400BC.
Total Flex is gym-quality and made of forged steel. Both the seat and back rest have thick foam padding for extra comfort and support. Best of all, Total Flex comes virtually assembled so all you have to do is slide it out of the box and attach the second Power Pod.
THE MOST EFFECTIVE PHYTOCERAMIDES ON AMAZON – Kaybo Health's Phytoceramides only use premium quality, scientifically tested ingredients, and vegetarian capsules. Manufactured in the USA, in an FDA-approved facility with strict adherence to Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP).
KayBo Health is dedicated to providing our customers with the best quality weight loss and beauty supplements on the market today.
A wonderful place to start is all the monthly expenses we pay.
This interesting article addresses some of the key issues regarding Running a Bass Fishing Boat.
Comfortable, breathable and non restrictive allowing running and swimming with ease
The DeskCycle was specifically designed to be used in the work environment.
AMAZING 2.5% Retinol Protection – Fight against the signs of aging with Belitae Organics powerful Rejuvenate Retinol Serum. Reduce the appearance of sun damage, deep wrinkles, dark circles, fine lines, and hyperpigmentation for the face and eyes.
KayBo Health is committed to providing each customer with the highest standard of customer service.
Each muscle car is distinct however just some cars take care of to take the hearts of the motorists and also get countless fans.
Just what is it in bass fishing that everyone is driven on to involve on such a task? Individuals get keen on bass fishing that is why every trend that they become aware of truly apprehends their passions and as much as feasible enter it.
For more than thirty years the Monks of New Skete have been among America's most trusted authorities on dog training, canine behavior, and the animal/human bond.
Try creating new weight loss habits versus trying to stop harmful weight loss habits.
One of the highest concentrations of EPA (50%) and DHA (20%) on the market
Highest 5 star rating from IFOS (International Fish Oil Standards), the most stringent third party fish oil testing laboratory. See current batch report in product images at left.
Molecularly distilled USP-verified fish oil and produced under strict GMP standards in a state of the art facility in the USA
Clinical studies have found Phytoceramides to: – Promote Skin Smoothness – Eliminate Fine Lines & Wrinkles – Nourish, Restore, and Strengthen New Collagen, Reversing Damaged Skin – Remove Unsightly "Crow's Feet" – Improve Skin Firmness and Elasticity – Reduce Itchiness and Redness – Increase Skin Hydration
Our product is entirely manufactured in the United States in an FDA approved facility, under Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) and under the highest level of quality control. Each batch is 3rd party tested for purity.