With millions forced out of work and many more stuck at home, Canadians need to ask tough questions of organizations receiving billions of dollars to protect them from foreign threats. The country’s intelligence/security sector has done little to respond to the ongoing social and economic calamity. Even worse, their thinking and practices are an obstacle to what’s required to overcome a global pandemic.
A recent Canadian Press article highlights the failure of intelligence agencies to warn of the COVID-19 outbreak. They largely ignore health-related threats despite receiving huge sums of federal money.
The Canadian Security Intelligence Service’s (CSIS) has more than 3,000 employees and a $500 million budget, which is nearly equal to that of the lead agency dealing with the pandemic. The Public Health Agency of Canada’s (PHAC) budget is $675 million and it has 2,200 employees. For its part, the Communications Security Establishment (CSE) employs 2,500 and receives over $600 million annually. In 2011 Department of National Defence run CSE moved into a new $1.2 billion, 110,000 square meter, seven-building, complex connected to CSIS’ main compound.
CSE is but one component of DND’s intelligence juggernaut. Not counting CSE, the Canadian Forces has greater intelligence gathering capacities than any organization in the country. While their budget and size are not public information, the government’s 2017 Defence Policy review notes that "CFINTCOM [Canadian Forces Intelligence Command] is the only entity within the Government of Canada that employs the full spectrum of intelligence collection capabilities while providing multi-source analysis." The Defence Policy Paper called for adding 300 military intelligence positions and expanding CFINTCOM’s scope.
CFINTCOM has a medical intelligence (MEDINT) cell to track how global health trends and contagions impact military operations. Apparently, they reported on the coronavirus outbreak in January but it’s unclear who received that information.
The $2 billion spent on CSIS/CSE/CFINTCOM annually – let alone the more than $30 billion devoted to DND/Veterans Affairs – could have purchased a lot of personal protective equipment for health care workers. It could have paid for many ventilators and it could also have been used to raise the abysmally low wages of many who work in long-term care and nursing homes.
But, it’s not only that CSIS/CSE/CFINTCOM resources could be better used. Their ideology and structures are an obstacle to avoiding/overcoming a global pandemic. Two weeks ago, CSE put out a statement warning Canadian coronavirus researchers to beware of malign international forces seeking to steal their research. A Canadian Centre for Cyber Security statement noted, "these actors may attempt to gain intelligence on COVID-19 response efforts and potential political responses to the crisis or to steal ongoing key research toward a vaccine or other medical remedies." But, wouldn’t it, in fact, be great if our ‘enemies’ in Russia, China, Iran, or anywhere else employed Canadian research to develop a cure or vaccine for COVID-19? Who, except extreme right-wing ideologues could believe a vaccine or cure should be patented and profited from?
It won’t be easy to shift their orientation to include pandemics. In a recent commentary, prominent intelligence agency insider Wesley Wark notes, "our security and intelligence agencies have never seen health emergency reporting as part of their core mandate, despite a plan laid down in the National Security Policy announced after SARS that unfortunately went nowhere." For a time after the 2003 SARS outbreak the CSIS-based Integrated Threat Assessment Centre reported regularly on pandemic dangers, but the unit was soon collapsed into the Integrated Terrorism Assessment Centre. For the intelligence agencies "terrorism" is appealing because it justifies militarism and a ‘security’ state. Health emergencies, on the other hand, justify better work conditions for long-term care providers.
The CSIS/CSE/CFINTCOM definition of ‘security’ is heavily shaped by corporate Canada, state power projection and ties to the US Empire. In criticizing Canadian intelligence agencies’ failure to warn/protect us from the pandemic, Wark highlights the dangerously narrow outlook of the intelligence community. He suggests CSIS/CSE/CFINTCOM could have helped prevent the calamity by gathering better intelligence on China. But, if Beijing hid early information on COVID-19, it’s at least partly because China is locked in a destructive geopolitical competition with the US empire, which was instigated by Washington and its allies (from 1949 to 1970 Canada refused to recognize China and in 1950 sent 27,000 troops to Korea largely to check Chinese nationalism). In recent months CSIS/CSE/CFINTCOM have sought to identify China as a threat.
Wark’s thinking must be rejected. Avoiding and overcoming global pandemics requires a free exchange of health information. It also requires international solidarity.
After the COVID-19 crisis dies down, progressives should renew their push to devote intelligence agencies’ resources towards initiatives that protect ordinary Canadians’ security, rather than the interests of the rich and powerful.
Yves Engler is the author of ten books, including his latest,Left, Right – Marching to the Beat of Imperial Canada.
Like the USA, Canada pretends that “intelligence ” and “defense” mean protection by/from violence in the military sense, not the real events such as pandemics which real “intelligence” has already told them are likely.
I love seeing terms like “Canadian intelligence,” to begin with. Then to find out that the story is about a “professor” from the University of Zero, is a double treat.
Guess CanSec don’t have all that much access to China, do they? Not with all the Canucks repatriated, or in a slammer.
Canada had excellent access to China and Asia; the best kind, forged over decades of trust and personal relationships from the days of Norman Bethune.
During the heyday of the Canadian Wheat Board, Canada even defied the U.S. to sell grain to China at the height of the Cultural Revolution famines. That overt independence bought respect.
The visible end began under PM Harper with the sale of the Canadian Wheat Board to a U.S.-Saudi conglomerate and topped with PM Trudeau’s arrest of Chinese telecom princess Meng.
Canada went from a first class intel power in Asia to a backwater dependent on foreign sources for China intel.
Ms Meng and her extradition put paid to that fine history. Reset to zero.
With the Coronavirus all over the world, new strains will be evolving, and will depend on the selection pressures on the virus in a given country, combined with pure random chance. It is inevitable that some new strains will be milder and some will be much worse. Just wait until one of those new worse strains starts ripping around the world. That is when the stuff really hits the fan.
Actually, Canadian Military Intelligence did issue a warning. Its just that the civilian intel bureacracy is wholly on board with globalism and pandemic panic.
“Canadian military intelligence unit issued warning about Wuhan outbreak back in January” – Murray Brewster, CBC, Apr 10, 2020.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/coronavirus-pandemic-covid-canadian-military-intelligence-wuhan-1.5528381
The Canadian Deep State is less nationalist and more globalist (and certainly, anti-Trumpian). Globalist neocon PM Trudeau has stated that lockdown culture will persist until a vaccine is found.
There seems to be no penetrating that faux-progressive echo-chamber of willful obtuseness at any level.
Canada, unlike the U.S., has few popular platforms of real news and dissent. Even the CBC seems more like an arm of the Communications Security Establishment than a real public broadcaster.
With democracy foiled by the non-elected Privy Council, Canada is a non-player in human liberty.
Canadian moral leadership kind of fell apart after Mulroney carved CSIS out of the RCMP and created an American-style security establishment; that is, one removed from political democratic accountability.
Trump was right to close the border to Canada; Canada is sadly a liability to American/North American independence from neocon globalist imperialism.
The U.S. economy can recover without Canada, fortunately.