Enemies of the Warfare State: Government Spying on Peaceful Political Dissidents

John Glaser, April 03, 2013


Just-released declassified documents reveal new details about government surveillance of peaceful political activism in the name of fighting terrorism:

Government documents obtained by the Partnership for Civil Justice Fund (PCJF) through its FOIA records requests reveal that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), an agency created after the September 11 attacks under the rubric of combating terrorism, conducts daily monitoring of peaceful, lawful protests as a matter of policy.

Functioning as a secret political police force against people participating in lawful, peaceful free speech activity, the heavily redacted documents show that the DHS “Threat Management Division” directed Regional Intelligence Analysts to provide a “Daily Intelligence Briefing” that includes a category of reporting on “Peaceful Activist Demonstrations” along with “Domestic Terrorist Activity.” (p. 68)

The nationwide surveillance system has become the contemporary version of J. Edgar Hoover’s Gestapo-style FBI, watching, subverting, and harassing political dissenters in an extra-legal environment that disregards the First Amendment.

The DHS has used the inflated powers granted to it post-9/11 to expand the definition of “domestic terrorist” to anyone who disagrees with the government and acts on it. Senate investigations on what are called “fusion centers” – essentially DHS intelligence-sharing centers – concluded they did not act to disrupt terrorist plots and spent most of their time monitoring and trying to disrupt political dissidents, specifically “Ron Paul supporters, the ACLU, activists on both sides of the abortion debate, war protesters and advocates of gun rights.”

Muslim communities across the nation have been acutely spied on, intimidated, and persecuted by the FBI and DHS, as revealing Associated Press investigations have repeatedly demonstrated. More than that, as Trevor Aaronson’s new book The Terror Factory painstakingly documents, Muslims have also served as a scapegoat under an elaborate system of entrapment that targets vulnerable lowlifes with little capacity to do harm absent FBI enabling.

In the summer of 2011, The Washington Post reported on “a mysterious, ongoing nationwide terrorism investigation [by the FBI] with an unusual target: prominent peace activists and politically active labor organizers.”

The apparent targets, all vocal and visible critics of U.S. foreign policy in the Middle East and South America, deny any ties to terrorism. They say the government, using its post-9/11 focus on terrorism as a pretext, is targeting them for their political views.

They are “public non-violent activists with long, distinguished careers in public service, including teachers, union organizers and antiwar and community leaders,” said Michael Deutsch, a Chicago lawyer and part of a legal team defending those who believe they are being targeted by the investigation.

Think of the resources – billions of dollars and massive human effort – wasted on abridging the free speech rights of America’s political dissidents. This is what happens when the government is given the power and a blank check to perform seemingly legitimate functions like protecting us from terrorists.

But since there is not enough of a terrorist threat to obstruct, the state has been busy countering the real threat they face: dissent.

That existing threat, notably, only becomes truly menacing to the state when it gets attention, so it’s no surprise that the most recent set of documents released by PCJF show DHS exhibiting particular concern about protests getting media attention:

The documents show a Department of Homeland Security that appears obsessed with the question of whether any and all protests that are being surveilled receive media attention and coverage. Reporting within the DHS on media coverage of First Amendment protected activities, even in the smallest places, appears to be a routine part of DHS intelligence reports. None of the documents explain why media coverage of peaceful demonstrations is of interest to law enforcement or concerns “homeland security” in any way.

“This production of documents, like the FBI documents that the PCJF received in December 2012, is a window into the nationwide scope of DHS and FBI surveillance, monitoring, and reporting on peaceful protestors organizing with the Occupy movement. Taken together, the two sets of documents paint a disturbing picture of federal law enforcement agencies using their vast power in a systematic effort to surveil and disrupt peaceful demonstrations. The federal agencies’ actions were not because Occupy represented a ‘terrorist threat’ or a ‘criminal threat’ but rather because it posed a significant grassroots political challenge to the status quo,” stated Mara Verheyden-Hilliard, Executive Director of the PCJF.

Expansive as these powers and abuses of power are, government is always trying to broaden the scope of its capacities in this respect. Late last year, the Obama administration unilaterally granted new powers to The National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC), a sweeping database housing information and surveillance records of people the government suspects have ties to terrorism.

The Wall Street Journal:

The rules now allow the little-known National Counterterrorism Center to examine the government files of U.S. citizens for possible criminal behavior, even if there is no reason to suspect them. That is a departure from past practice, which barred the agency from storing information about ordinary Americans unless a person was a terror suspect or related to an investigation.

Now, NCTC can copy entire government databases—flight records, casino-employee lists, the names of Americans hosting foreign-exchange students and many others. The agency has new authority to keep data about innocent U.S. citizens for up to five years, and to analyze it for suspicious patterns of behavior. Previously, both were prohibited. Data about Americans “reasonably believed to constitute terrorism information” may be permanently retained.

The lesson here is the same one that has been learned and relearned by Americans over and over again throughout the history of the country: national security is always used as an excuse to expand government power and abridge the rights of citizens.

30 Responses to “Enemies of the Warfare State: Government Spying on Peaceful Political Dissidents”

  1. Dang – my Unitarian friends are in danger.

  2. Bizarro Orwellian Amerika.
    "I find your lack of patriotic obedience disturbing."…Peter 'IRA' King
    Unitarians are in danger as would be Quakers, Libertarians, AnarchoCapitalists, Justin Raimondo, Kelley Vlahos, and Skeet the glamorized Labrodoodle. You see, Skeet is somewhat gender challenged and therefore a mite suspicious.

  3. I dont know whats worse; the fact the government is doing this or that very few people actually care

  4. […] Antiwar.com Blog […]

  5. I am personally aware of the priority of spying on Americans rather than the Arabic-speaking al Qaida. I am a non-Arab and Christian who speaks and reads Arabic, having also lived with Bedouins. I thought I would be in demand by the FBI, etc., for translation work. You keep reading how critical this language is, right? Yeah, right. Neither my congressman nor senator care to follow up on why they aren't hiring. This article clearly shows why: you don't need an interpreter to spy on Americans.

  6. […] Govt Spying on Peaceful Political Dissidents […]

  7. Well, at least somebody is listening to me.

  8. To John Glaser:

    Thanks so much for this article. When I first read about this story a few months back, I thought immediately of COINTELPRO and wondered if our local police department had been contacted by the DHS &/or FBI with either request for assistance in spying on local Occupy activists or notification that such spying would be undertaken by DHS-FBI. My idea at the time, and I think it's one worth trying in any town with active dissenters to the corporate war state, was to put together a delegation of citizens to make public, media-covered visits to both our mayor and the police chief to ask them whether they'd received any communications from DHS-FBI and whether they'd either directly participated in spying on local dissent activities or known that it was going on. The goals of such action would be to increase public awareness of the government spying, express our opposition to it and to any city involvement with it, and take a step in holding the city government accountable in the future, both in the case that we found they hadn't been honest with us and in the case that they were faced down the road with choices to allow and perhaps participate in spying on our citizenry who chose to exercise their rights to criticize the status quo.

    My question for you: Do you have more information about the specific ways in which DHS-FBI not just "monitored" Occupy and other nonviolent protest groups but actually infiltrated and "disrupted" those groups' activities?

  9. Remember, Americans spying on Americans…wellcome to the former DDR or get used to your new name: USSA.

  10. This is the outcome of 9/11 and we are main victim of american policies.

  11. Now there's a pair that sums up the nation. Two gays discussing the tactics to be used on American citizens.

  12. […] http://antiwar.com/blog/2013/04/03/enemies-of-the-warfare-state-government-spying-on-peaceful-politi… […]

  13. […] http://antiwar.com/blog/2013/04/03/enemies-of-the-warfare-state-government-spying-on-peaceful-politi… […]

  14. Yep — FBI sent an informant to infiltrate Occupy Cleveland, he befriended a handful of fringe members of Occupy and led them into a pretend plot to blow up a bridge…. although Occupy immediately denounced the plot, it was good enough to bring Occupy Cleveland to a screeching halt.
    also there is the notorious case of Brandon Darby, for that i suggest you get yourself a copy of the great documentary "Better this World" http://www.defendingdissent.org/program/dissent.h

  15. Welcome to the Brave New World Order. The USSA is officially a corrupt, secret police state. I am so proud to me a New Amerkan, Sieg Heil!! ?

  16. […] Glaser, April 03, 2013 Print This | Share This | […]

  17. It`s really a great post. I am sure that anyone would like to visit it again and again. After reading this post I got some very unique information which are really very helpful for anyone. This is a post having some crucial information.

  18. This goes way back. Even double agent Lee Harvey Oswald spied on Antiwar Pacifists before this Jack Rubenstein, operating in a cleanup mode, exterminated the patsy.. .http://jfkcountercoup.blogspot.com/2010/08/cnva-quebec-guantamano-peace-march.html

  19. This is the outcome of 9/11 and we are main victim of american policies.

  20. Your blog post is really informative for me. I think I have read the same kind of information somewhere else but in different manner. Thanks and keep posting new things

  21. The NSA and the US Strategic Command have been involved in illegal hacking, stalking, cyber attacking and harassing whistleblowers, critics and dissidents since 2003. They illegally hacked the Army's MWR website, USA today, Yahoo, Craigslist, Facebook, Stars and Stripes, Military Times and the Washington Post websites. They falsely accused 50,000 Americans of being terrorists, and the FBI spent millions following their false leads. None of the falsely accused were terrorists. USAA Insurance has also been involved in illegal spying and cyber attacking critics of their company. Robert Bohanek, a USAA lawyer and cyber attacker was arrested in Austin, Texas for soliciting sex from a 14 year old girl. StratCom, USAA and the NSA have tried to silence me, but I will continue to be vocal about their illegal activites.

  22. Remember, Americans spying on Americans…wellcome to the former DDR or get used to your new name: USSA.

  23. The Army, Bridget Serchak, a spokeswoman for the inspector general, told Bloomberg, paid Boeing for parts “that were proposed but never installed,” and “is paying for additional parts that they do not need and may not use.”

  24. Thanks for all your efforts that you have put in this. extremely fascinating

  25. We are waiting for the new ONE

  26. check out pay-as-you-go options in your search. Phone companies are bending over backwards to get your attention and your business. It's a great time to compare mobile phone deals. link for specifications

  27. mrrc maan fot this articcle is verry nice maan …

  28. I dont know whats worse; the fact the government is doing this or that very few people actually care

  29. It’s hard to tell with these Internet start ups if they’re really interested in building companies or if they’re just interested in the money. I can tell you, though..VENUS FACTOR REVIEWS

  30. I am very enjoyed for this blog. Its an informative topic. It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy..Draftkings