As tensions with North Korea continue to intensify, some have suggested the US press China to influence Pyongyang to calm down.
The first problem with this is that the US doesn’t have the best relationship with China right now because of a little thing called the Asia-Pivot, a hostile and confrontational foreign policy meant to militarily contain a rising China that poses no direct threat to the US. Washington has been using its military and economic might in Asia-Pacific to bolster China’s regional competitors. Beijing might not be in the mood to do Uncle Sam a favor.
The second reason such an approach is unlikely to bear fruit is because the US has insisted on maintaining a massive military presence and diplomatic base in South Korea ever since the unnecessary US intervention in the Korean War, for which Truman never sought formal approval from Congress. The remaining US stake in the Korean peninsula is perceived as a geo-political threat to neighboring China, which is wary of American dominance in the region already.
Matt Schiavenza at The Atlantic explains (via):
If China suddenly decided to cut ties to its mercurial neighbor, North Korea would almost certainly collapse.
That, precisely, is the point: China really, really doesn’t want North Korea to collapse. For one thing, the trickle of North Koreans currently crossing the border would turn into a flood, leaving China with a messy humanitarian situation on its hands. Secondly, a North Korean collapse would no doubt foster the creation of a unified, pro-U.S. Korea on China’s northeastern flank, depriving Beijing of a valuable buffer against American interest. For these reasons, China needs North Korea to stay alive — and North Korea knows it.
Like in Syria, where a political settlement assisted by world powers never materialized due to (justified) Russian and Chinese skepticism of letting Washington create another client state in the Middle East, the situation with North Korea is being perpetuated because everybody knows the US will stop at nothing to expand its empire.
As I’ve written, another option that would be very likely to mitigate the tensions with Pyongyang would of course be for the US to not constantly antagonize the North through provocative military activities with the South and, um, sending nuclear capable B-2 stealth bombers to drop munitions on a nearby island. That might work too.
"Like in Syria, where a political settlement assisted by world powers never materialized due to (justified) Russian and Chinese skepticism of letting Washington create another client state in the Middle East"
not quite sure what you mean by "political settlement", unless you mean the UN resolution that Russia and China vetoed. If that is the case it does not seem at all political to me because the result would have been the bombing and military destruction of the Syrian state.
Normally, I'd agree with the gist of your message above. This specific case of N-Korea is not the 'standard scenario' of installing puppets in ME or bombing brown people all over the world because of their belief. Rather, this issue should and must be addressed by China: the only power NK will respect. So, my conclusion would be to put international pressure on China to reign in their bloodhound.
I mean, when Israel has their yearly Palestine-Slaughter-Party, the world tries (without success) to ask US to reign in their butcher-of-the-middle-east. Analogously, the world shuld ask China to restrain their Nuke-Kid-On-The-Block.
I therefore disagree with your standard US bashing in this specific case.
Cutting slack to whatever despot is standard operating procedure for Anti-war so long as it bashes the American Empire.
Go back to sleep…if you are unable to accept that the US is the prime instigator in all of this then continue to believe US propaganda and outright lying regarding this situation. ZZzzz
You say in the same breath that the world seems incapable of getting the US to rein in Israel but should pressure China to do the same with North Korea.
What is there to resolve? North Korea didn't make any demands. It announed it's going to attack the U.S. with nuclear weapons. Then nothing happened. Now it's announced it's going to attack the U.S. with nuclear weapons again. Now everyone is waiting to see whether they will or not…
Seems to me if the Chinese want to avoid the "Asian Pivot", and more militarization of the Korean peninsula, then pressuring the N. Koreans to calm down is a no brainer.
I think it is impossible for China to avoid an "Asian Pivot". If they can manage to rein in N Korea then we will just push harder (as we did against Libya after Gadaffi moderated).
Their only rational course is, i think, to be firm, but not shoot first.
Eventually we'll run out of funds for these adventures, and that will be the end of it.
The Asia pivot is not going anywhere, America is too poor to contain China
Go back to sleep…if you are unable to accept that the US is the prime instigator in all of this then continue to believe US propaganda and outright lying regarding this situation. ZZzzz
Let’s make one thing clear: these useless military exercises and demonstrations of force do absolutely nothing to alter the reality or Russia’s strategic calculations. They are essentially for domestic consumption, to satisfy political hardliners who are attacking the president for being too weak.
Leta??s make one thing clear: these useless military exercises and demonstrations of force do absolutely nothing to alter the reality or Russiaa??s strategic calculations. They are essentially for domestic consumption, to satisfy political hardliners who are attacking the president for being too weak.
Thanks for all your efforts that you have put in this. extremely fascinating
Be aware of war, Koreans should prefer peace and work for peaceful world. When you need help of essay writing service, here are best writers who are expert in professional writing help providing. Thanks for sharing this beautifully researched post for readers of blog.
This website shows again and again that war is not profitable. It cause nothing but destruction. Should be avoided with all means…
I want to bring a different perspective on the matters.
A war between the north and south Korea will be devastating in human life and destruction. So we should avoid it in all means. And applying sanctions against North Korea hurts the people, not the regime.
As I have composed, another choice that would be most likely to minimize the tensions with Pyongyang would of course be to the US never to continuously antagonize the North through provocative army activities using the To the south and, um, sending nuclear able B-2 stealth bombers to drop munitions with a surrounding tropical island. That might work too.
"Like in Syria, where a political settlement assisted by world powers never materialized due to (justified) Russian and Chinese skepticism of letting Washington create another client state in the Middle East"
not quite sure what you mean by "political settlement", unless you mean the UN resolution that Russia and China vetoed. If that is the case it does not seem at all political to me because the result would have been the bombing and military destruction of the Syrian st
"That, precisely, is the point: China really, really doesn’t want North Korea to collapse. For one thing, the trickle of North Koreans currently crossing the border would turn into a flood, leaving China with a messy humanitarian situation on its hands. "… I dont totally agree. North Korea will collapse in one time or another.
Like in Syria, where a political settlement assisted by world powers never materialized due to (justified) Russian and Chinese skepticism of letting Washington create another client state in the Middle East, the situation with North Korea is being perpetuated because everybody knows the US will stop at nothing to expand its empire.
That, precisely, is the point: China really, really doesn’t want North Korea to collapse. For one thing, the trickle of North Koreans currently crossing the border would turn into a flood, leaving China with a messy humanitarian situation on its hands. Secondly, a North Korean collapse would no doubt foster the creation of a unified, pro-U.S. Korea on China’s northeastern flank, depriving Beijing of a valuable buffer against American interest. For these reasons, China needs North Korea to stay alive — and North Korea knows it.
That, precisely, could be the stage: China truly, genuinely doesn’t would like N . Korea to break down. For starters, the actual drip of N . Koreans presently crossing your boundary would turn into a deluge, departing China using a untidy non profit situation upon its hands. Secondly, the North Korean fail might without doubt create the growth of the single, pro-U.Azines. South korea about China’s east flank, depriving Beijing of a important load against National attention. Thereby, Cina wants Northern South korea to stay alive – and North Korea is aware it.
Where would you start off? For starters, try and remove smokes, sophisticated glucose, saturated fats, as well as too much consumption of alcoholic beverages. We all know in which so-called health professionals usually contradict on their own in relation to precisely what constitutes undue utilization of some goods. Though the uniformity in which these items have already been fingered in a lot of health conditions suggests that anyone usually takes their own health critically must watch where did they start using these points. Along with true of cigarettes, there is certainly zero safe and sound volume!
Another point to consider this strategy isn't likely to deal with fresh fruit is really because the united states has was adament about sustaining a massive armed service existence and also diplomatic base inside South Korea since the unwanted People involvement inside the Mandarin chinese War, which is why Truman by no means looked for formal authorization from Our elected representatives. The residual Us all risk from the Mandarin chinese peninsula will be considered the geo-political danger to nearby Tiongkok, that's cautious with U . s . importance in the region by now.
In which, precisely, could be the point: Tiongkok really, really doesn’t need N . South korea to collapse. For instance, the actual spill regarding Upper Koreans at the moment crossing the particular edge would turn into a ton, leaving behind China having a untidy relief predicament on the arms. Subsequently, a North Mandarin chinese fall would no doubt create the creation of a new specific, pro-U.Utes. Korea on China’s northeastern flank, starving China of your beneficial barrier towards National interest. Therefore, Cina requirements Upper South korea to keep in existence * as well as North Korea knows this.
Like in Syria, the place where a politics negotiation aided through planet powers never ever materialized due to (justified) European along with Chinese hesitation associated with allowing California generate an additional customer condition in the Middle Eastern, your situation together with Northern South korea is being perpetuated because everyone understands the united states will stop at absolutely nothing to develop its empire.
In which, precisely, could be the point: Tiongkok really, really doesn’t need N . South korea to collapse. For instance, the actual spill regarding Upper Koreans at the moment crossing the particular edge would tur ,,,,
Let’s make one thing clear: these useless military exercises and demonstrations of force do absolutely nothing to alter the reality or Russia’s strategic calculations. They are essentially for domestic consumption, to satisfy political hardliners who are attacking the president for being too weak.
I’m cheerful that such fantastic website exist. .